Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
195printed page
scan 209 of 434

195

if we fail to convince them, that is also fine with us. For frankly, these humbly suffering and hoping people, who lay their hands in their laps and wait until a fist from the clouds grabs them by the scruff of the neck and carries them through the air to the promised land, are not a first-rate desirable element in a people that must stir itself vigorously to build a new, viable community with resolute self-help. The second mystical objection is that the Jews are supposed to have the mission of being role models and teachers to the other nations, and that Zionism prevents them from fulfilling this mission, as it calls them away from their professorial chairs and model tables in the midst of the nations. I completely renounce refuting this objection. I really could not do it in parliamentary terms. I leave it to the antisemites to mock the megalomaniacal self-aggrandizement of the poor fools who, amidst the laughter and kicks of the nations, deck themselves out with cotillion medals and paper crowns and call out to the jeering crowd: "Behold, I am your teacher and role model!" We do not suffer from such a delirium. We want, in all modesty, first of all to live, and then to educate ourselves into a model people. If the other nations later wish to take the reborn Jewish people as an example, it will be a great honor for us, which we will make every effort to deserve. But to impose ourselves as teachers upon the nations that want to know nothing of us—that is a thought for which there is no room in our heads.

The two mystical objections, that Zionism preempts Providence and that it disturbs the mission of the Jews, we can therefore disregard. Only the three other objections: Zionism is unfeasible, it is a danger

13*