Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
192printed page
scan 206 of 434

tums also into his new existence. Furthermore, he must renounce all personal ambition; he must strictly forbid himself from striving for the development of his abilities, for success and fame, in any area of human, civic activity. For if he distinguishes himself in the slightest and thereby arouses the inevitable envy of outdone competitors, he can count with deadly certainty on having his Jewish origins used to trip him up and on stumbling over it just as he would have if he had remained a proud confessor of his Judaism—perhaps not more, but certainly not less. Thus, in order to become an adoptee by the method of disappearing, of submerging, the individual Jew-shy Semite must be a completely obscure personality and remain so his whole life with iron steadfastness. He himself cannot hope to reap in his lifetime the advantage he promises himself from the denial of his tribe and of himself. This advantage benefits at most his children or grandchildren; the method thus indeed contains a great deal of pie in the sky, at least as much as Zionism, probably considerably more than it.

And note that everything I have said so far applies only to the individual. As soon as one tries to apply the method of going under and disappearing on a large scale, one faces a sheer impossibility that actually does not even deserve to be discussed. For one thing, the great mass of Jews has no intention of abandoning their Judaism and, even in this age of religious indifference, would still rather suffer persecution and death than fall away from their faith, their traditions, their distinct peoplehood. But secondly, even if the unbelievable