Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
168printed page
scan 182 of 434

168 of the wording and sense of a resolution of the Sixth Congress has given it the name of an extraordinary Congress. I will therefore not dwell on this highly significant matter now.

The deep, yet deliberate longing for the land of our fathers, which undoubtedly inspires every Zionist, which is what makes him a Zionist in the first place, has taken the form of a nervous impatience among a portion of our like-minded associates, who believe they can wait no longer. And since it does not depend on us to obtain the land of our longing immediately under the conditions in which alone the return to the old homeland would be a blessing for our people and the solution to the Jewish question, they want to fall back on the methods of small-scale colonization condemned by experience, without a foundation in public law and without the prior conclusion of a bilateral treaty with the government of His Majesty the Sultan. You will have to take a position on the vital question of whether Zionism should return to its pre-Herzlian origins, whether it should again become a so-called practical Choveve-Zionism and, with a tremendous effort by the entire Jewish people, settle a few dozen families in Palestine as subsidized colonists of solace and hope, or whether it should continue on the path forged by Herzl and remain a great world-political movement that will not rest until it has, with the consent and cooperation of the Powers, created normal conditions of existence for the entire Jewish people, for their salvation and for the benefit of civilization. I may well express the hope that your wisdom will find a middle way that allows us to at least partially satisfy the impatient ones, without letting Zionism shrink back to the embryonic forms it had in the eighties.