Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
123printed page
scan 137 of 434

123

dressed, poorly equipped with study materials, without verve, without freedom of mind, without that breath of distinction that science otherwise spreads about its disciples. The more fortunate fellow students, who have no feeling for the tragedy of his hollow cheeks and his threadbare coat, despise the beggar-student. The teachers feel a deep aversion to the pupil, whom they consider incapable and lazy, although he develops a superhuman diligence—admittedly, in a direction other than the one they rightly demand—and they arrive at a generalizing antisemitism from which even so free a spirit as Billroth could not protect himself. During his studies, the beggar-student is a proletarian; in the exam, he is a gambler; with the diploma in his pocket, he once again becomes a person of no substance. Thus arises among us the dreadful paradox that study, which for every other people opens the door to a higher social position, does not elevate among us, but possibly even debases. The poor Jew who raises himself to a learned profession does not cease to be a proletarian, but rather proletarianizes every learned profession which he penetrates in any significant number. He is himself inferior, and his poverty forces him to put a low price on his services. That this is not a matter of a lack of ability, earnestness, or a sense of duty, but only a lack of working capital, is proven by the tiny minority of those Jewish students who come from the prosperous middle class and can actually study during their university years, instead of having to earn a living for themselves and even for their families. From these few well-situated students emerge, in disproportionately large numbers, the leading intellectual lights.