120
neither a lack of aptitude nor insufficient diligence, but rather a shockingly incomplete technical training. How, under the given circumstances, is a Jew to become a competent craftsman? He has no industrial tradition of his own. In the ghetto, only the most rudimentary and simplest crafts were practiced. The better trades were organized into guilds, and the guilds did not admit any Jews. Even when freedom of trade was granted, Christian masters could hardly be persuaded to take on Jewish apprentices. Where was the Jew to learn a proper trade? Where was he to find a connection to the technical traditions that are the legacy of two millennia of skill, diligence, love of labor, and professional pride of the artisan class of all civilized nations?
The Jewish craftsman, insofar as his work is not of a kind that one does not really need to learn at all, is an autodidact, and such a person must be almost a genius in his special field in order not to be effortlessly beaten in competition by the properly trained professional. The fact that Jews are outstanding goldsmiths and jewelers, and occasionally also artistic locksmiths and precision mechanics, borders on the miraculous, for they have had to become so on their own, with virtually no instruction.
The few fields in which Jews attain a proper training are immediately monopolized by them. I will mention only diamond cutting. Beside them, simply no one else can compete. The vast majority of Jewish craftsmen, however, stagnate in tailoring, shoemaking, and cap making, which require no physical strength and no particular manual dexterity, and even in these trades they remain with the production of the most common and therefore worst-paid goods, which require no mental ef-