Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
118printed page
scan 132 of 434

fished a little, begged a little, stole a little, and idled a lot. But from these dubious figures, who hover at the margins of normal economic life between professional beggary and crime, the Jewish Luftmensch is distinguished by the fact that he is thoroughly honest, able-bodied, and willing to work, yet is artificially excluded from any reasonably productive labor.

Many Luftmenschen together make a Luftvolk. Indeed, the Jewish people is a Luftvolk. Literally, because it does not have a square foot of its own soil and hangs completely in the air; figuratively, because it has no firm economic ground under its feet and lives, like the individual Luftmensch, day to day on miracles and fabulous coincidences, not on a regular, secure income.

III.

We Jews are called a people of merchants. On superficial observation, we also seem to be this. But we really are not. In the economically justified, because necessary, wholesale trade, which buys useful goods where they are available in abundance and brings them to where they are lacking and desired, our people have a very small share. It engages mainly in superfluous retail. There are Jewish cities and towns where every Jew offers something for sale to his neighbor, who repays him this favor.

In practice, this amounts to every shop having a single customer: its owner. Even where conditions are a tiny bit more favorable, they are still extremely difficult and insecure. For