Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
114printed page
scan 128 of 434

how many rural inhabitants? What occupations does the Jewish people pursue? How does it work, what does it own? What does it eat and drink? How does it live? How does it dress? How much of its income does it spend on food, clothing, housing, and intellectual needs? All this one must know if one truly wants to know a people. As long as one does not know this, everything one wants to do for the people is a fumbling in the dark; everything one says about this people is, at best, poetry, at worst, empty chatter.

Certainly, even among the richest and most civilized peoples there are not many who know about themselves in the ideally complete way that I wish for the Jewish people. But the peoples who can sit on their own soil in a normal way and let themselves live, without having to think about the theoretical presuppositions and consequences of their existence, can more easily dispense with the brightest statistical illumination than we, who are to erect a new national structure from the ground up. Ancient buildings that have already defied centuries or millennia continue to exist empirically, whether one knows their ground plan and elevation and the nature of their building material or not. But if one wants to build a new house, the drawing up of a plan and the testing of the strength of the building material to be used is indispensable.

To fulfill this demand, almost nothing has been done so far. No one can justifiably be blamed for this. Even in fully equipped states, which have money, expert statisticians, and a powerful administration that finds obedience everywhere, the implementation of comprehensive statistics that are at the cutting edge of science is an extremely tedious, difficult, and