Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
106printed page
scan 120 of 434

106

separated from their cries for help by the world's oceans. But what is to become of them in America? Will they be left to perish there? Are they to die there one by one? Is a man who starves to death in America any less dead than a man who dies of hunger in Romania or between the Romanian border and Rotterdam? Will they continue to be given alms in America as well? Then the weak characters would immediately be turned into professional beggars, and even the more capable ones would soon succumb to the temptation of allowing themselves to be permanently supported as certified paupers. Or is there the intention to show the newcomers suitable places for settlement in America, to guide them into stable professions, to help them toward economic independence? That would require a powerful organization, and I do not yet see the slightest beginning of such an organization. Mere planless, occasional charity is laughably insufficient, or rather, it is frighteningly insufficient for the demands that the current situation places upon the Jewish people. And even this headless, automatic distribution of alms will one day suddenly cease. Has anyone calculated what sum it requires? In America, no Romanian Jew may land who cannot prove possession of 125 Francs. With the fare and the cost of living up to the port of embarkation, this requires at least 300 Francs for each individual. If only 100,000 of the 270,000 Romanian Jews were to make use of this charity, we already arrive at a minimum amount of 30 million Francs, to which the administrative costs and other unproductive, yet unavoidable, expenses must be added.

And what is achieved with these 30 million, which represent the minimum requirement? With that, it is simply