15 lects are used by both the Nubians in southern Egypt and the Abyssinians. The Jews themselves today speak all the languages of the world, just not their own. The Negroes of North America speak exclusively English, those of South America only Spanish; how great, however, would be the error to infer race from their dialect!
Although language, as well as other cultural assets, retains a subordinate, in a way historical, value, since it can, when anthropological factors have previously pointed us in that direction, significantly facilitate our recognition of many racial and ethnic shifts, it may therefore never, ever be used without such indicators as a starting point for a racial classification. With full justification, an Indo-Germanic race assumed from mere linguistic affinity is therefore today described as scientific nonsense. It is, after all, well known that there are more similarities between Northern Aryans and Finns on the one hand, and between Southern Aryans and Semites on the other, than, for instance, between Norwegians and Sicilians. *
- Incidentally, we are convinced that even the study of so-called linguistic affinity itself, once this problem is thoroughly worked on by experts in an original manner uninfluenced by tradition, will not yield the hitherto seemingly unambiguous results.
From recent publications by Wirth (Polit.-anthrop. Revue, 1907; Kafische Zusammenhänge [Caucasian Connections]) it emerges that in the most ancient times historically accessible to us, a group of people may have been settled between the Caucasian and Tibetan highlands, which already in these earliest times would have sent its colonies and its culture in all directions to the most distant regions, especially towards Europe, the residues of which are still preserved in old geographical designations and ethnic names. That on such traffic routes indirect linguistic connections can also arise merely per contiguitatem even between the most unrelated peoples is a fact noticeable in all phases of history.
If this hypothesis could claim some probability for itself — and some of Wirth's arguments cannot be dismissed out of hand — it would provide a means to explain to us the linguistic connections of the peoples living south of this group, including the Indians, and the Slavo-Germanic and Southern European peoples living north and west of it.
