397 of "religiously withdrawing into oneself" and "contemplation" may well condition individual happiness and indifference to the adversities of life; — yet this is a happiness which, in the long run, would have to degenerate into unhappiness, because it precludes cultural progress. Positive religion must not exhaust itself in religious thought, but must promote cultural progress. An ideal religion would have to correspond in equal measure to the inner religious need as to the need to promote culture, and be appropriate for the individual as well as the social need for happiness. The essence of Judaism as a religion, however, is not merely religion in a metaphysical sense—though, as just explained, it is also that!—but rather state "law" and "doctrine." These are authoritatively supported only by the "faith" in certain theophanies, and for the purpose of objectification and materialization, are bound to certain forms of worship. This faith and cult were indispensable instruments up to the present day, but they were not the essence. It is well enough known that the "Mosaic" confession is not only religious doctrine, but state, social, and even hygienic law.* *
- *
- The mention of Moses leads us to a for our subject very important point. In response to the bold assertion that there has never been ideality, genius, and characters of world-historical, political significance among the Jews, we want to point out that the greatest character and most far-sighted statesman that world history knows at all, was the lawgiver of the Jews. Despite the concern of being cumulative, we cannot deny ourselves bringing, in a longer note, an excerpt from a little-known lecture on Moses that the national economist Henry George gave in Glasgow in the eighties: The opinion has formed among us moderns to see in the great characters of history more the result than the cause of the respective currents of the time. Just as in earlier times the great historical events were attributed to persons, so we