Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
XXXIIprinted page
scan 36 of 568

XXXII. Book. Here the writings of Stratz are the object, which were indeed cited, but at most deemed worthy of a cursory reading.

To return now to the matter itself, it is quite understandable when Sombart speaks in the foreword of having felt a "tormenting feeling of dissatisfaction, of imbalance" in view of the III. Main Section, which seeks to answer the question of the origin of the Jewish nature and of its own essence. We can only repeat that, in our opinion, this part of his system is completely unfounded. However, to support this assertion of mine, I will not content myself with referring to my expositions on the philosophy of history and the theory of heredity, but will also endeavor to comply with the author's demand to proceed from empirical-historical factuality in any potential refutation.

Just as the economic mindset that lives in the Bible is strictly traditionalistic, i.e., averse to the capitalist view: "Let every man abide by his sustenance, and let the godless strive for gain," so too in the present day is the nature corresponding to the capitalist view not the fundamental direction of the Jewish psyche to the extent that Sombart believes. Admittedly, there is indeed much stunting of genuine character here, ideals are indeed often thrown overboard as useless ballast in order to be able to take on full loads of practical interests, and as with the modern city dweller in general, the development towards a form as colorless and un-national as possible, to the "gray, boring, monotonous American man" is in fact unmistakable. But this is certainly not the general type of the Jewish people. The majority of those Jews who still represent the general type of the people are practically attached to the soil. The geographical redistribution currently taking place as a result of migrations is, just like most earlier ones, only explainable by the catastrophic external circumstances. In the beginnings of the current emigration, the groups of emigrants consisted predominantly of two categories: