Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
XXVIIIprinted page
scan 32 of 568

XXVIII ge a scale that a statistician recently gave the — undoubtedly exaggerated — estimate that 70 percent of the capital acquired by Jews is "de-Judaized" again (Nachzahl), then the deeper truth about these "facts" of Jewish wealth and its continuity emerges most clearly. The assertion that already in antiquity money-lending was the true life principle of the genuine Hebrews, who did not cultivate the land, but "presumably" sat in the cities as lords of rent and interest, is almost a pure product of fantasy manufactured ad hoc, for Sombart himself makes no serious attempt at proof here, and the documentary evidence that can be ascertained from the literature speaks almost compellingly against it. And finally, one more "fact" to be corrected should be highlighted. "Like the sun, Israel passes over Europe; where it comes, new life sprouts; from where it departs, everything that once blossomed now decays." The present book certainly contains no belittling of the merits of the Jewish race, but the quoted sentence, which even with reduced content could still be an important motto for Russian and Turkish statesmen, surely goes much too far. It is certainly a flaw in the presentation to attribute the tremendous, world-spanning development of the modern economy to the Jews to the extent that Sombart does. These are the supporting ideas of his system, and their removal means no less than the elimination of the problem in the very form posited by Sombart, as well as the improbability of the type of solution he attempted. But independent of the constructed connection with economic conditions, his anthropological and ethno-psychological discussions are of practical, current, and especially of theoretical interest, and are particularly so intimately connected with the subject of my own theme, turning so to the general theoretical foundations of the Jewish question and of the race problem over-