Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
XXprinted page
scan 24 of 568
Facsimile · scan 24 of 568
Scan of p. XX
English · AI translation, not yet checked

XX because it pushes man away from the steaming soil, tears him away from organic nature, because it puts purposefulness in the place of joy in work. Just as the nomadic life, modern metropolitan life demands the development of purely rationalistic abilities, the qualities of constant purpose-mindedness, of adaptability, and of mobility. But it is capitalism that tears people everywhere from their paternal soil, that heaps the uprooted and the dispossessed of their homeland together in the big cities, where they become the nomads of the present time.

The fact that the oriental people of the Jews was now cast into the firmly enclosed conditions of Nordic peoples and entered into a cultural pairing with them, had to result in the world-historical significance of the Jews for economic life —and the "blessings" of our civilization.

Of course, a national economist like Sombart knows that the development towards modern economic forms with their, yes, ultimately in many ways truly happiness-destroying effects cannot be stopped and is not caused by the Jews alone, that the development of modern technology, the opening up of new parts of the world, the discovery of the silver treasures of America had a very significant share in it. Despite all this, this just-developed train of thought from Sombart's book, in conjunction with other works by the author, is perfectly clear. Since this train of thought, however, as far as I know, has not been recognized by any of his previous critics, but for the external effect of the book this very side is a very serious consideration, it seemed necessary for me to work it out myself in sharp outlines, in order now to take a stand with a few words against the supporting pillars of this thought structure in a similar way as I have already done in oral controversies with the author elsewhere.

For the time being, I am in a position to be content with brief references for the very reason that the detailed refutation of his views is precisely this present book