Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
138printed page
scan 190 of 568
Facsimile · scan 190 of 568
Scan of p. 138
English · AI translation, not yet checked

138 this region. Under these circumstances, the theory which Halévy has put forward and for which a number of the most distinguished Assyriologists have since advocated, namely that cuneiform script is of Semitic origin, deserves to be considered most carefully. Much speaks in its favor, much that can be explained more easily by it than by the opposing hypothesis, which Jules Oppert put forward and to which, with certain limitations, the majority of scholars still adhere today. "The first to declare himself a follower of Halévy was Guyard. Among younger scholars, Thureau-Daugin, the most important Assyriologist in France, who has devoted himself particularly to the study of ancient Babylonian history, takes an anti-Sumerian position. The same is done by Henri Pognon, another excellent French scholar. In Germany, Alfred Jeremias and Jäger are on Halévy's side. In America, two Assyriologists of the first rank, who are preeminently qualified as authorities to express an opinion on the complex problem, namely Prof. I. M. Price at the University of Chicago and Prof. J. F. Mc. Curdy at the one in Toronto, share the views of the Semitic origin of Babylonian culture, and Brinton also counted among Halévy's followers. In view of such endorsements, it would be foolish to simply dismiss the problem as a settled dispute. We are perhaps still far from a decision on the question. The most recent historical and archaeological research compels every conscientious scholar who is not content to merely parrot a traditional view to re-examine the problem carefully. Even if it turns out that Halévy is not right in every detail, his main theses, namely that Babylonian culture is of Semitic origin and that no conclusive proof of a former Sumerian-Akkadian language has yet been furnished, are nevertheless to be recommended. "Under these circumstances, an attempt to make an impartial decision in this controversy will have to be limited to roughly the following propositions: