82 arise about the usability of the cranial index in general, when it was found that, for example, the Indians, who possess a particularly striking uniformity of external type, at the same time exhibit the most diverse skull types in irregular distribution. The ancient Germanic peoples, after all, also appeared to Tacitus as a pure, unmixed race. Nevertheless, anthropology shows us that they were already composed of several types. Ranke alone demonstrated, among the population of Upper Bavaria, all hitherto determined racial skulls side by side.
After uncommonly detailed investigations, v. Török, who probably stands at the top with regard to the number of craniometric measurements he himself performed, came to the conclusion that "the entire view of gentes dolichocephalicae is obsolete. That originally each tribe had only one uniform skull shape and that all differences are conditioned only by blood mixing, is completely arbitrary and unproven. The entire related craniology has been moving for 60 years on a false and fruitless path, the Retzian index consideration is useless."**
Incidentally, Blumenbach was already seeking "the causes for the national differences of skulls" in climate (i.e., environment) and in deformations that were indeed hereditarily fixed, but originally artificial, and thus did not see a permanent type that had always existed, as present-day craniology does.
We wish to particularly point out here that our critique relates exclusively to the conditions among the white peoples and that it leaves out of consideration that dolichocephaly is found most pronouncedly precisely among the so-called savage peoples, i.e., among the Australians, Negroes, etc. Since, concerning these peoples, the objection was made that for them it is a matter of an occipital, i.e., conditioned by the protrusion of the occipital bone, but for the Germanic peoples a frontal dolichocephaly caused by the curvature of the frontal bone, we do not include these facts at all in our counter-argumentation.
* New Investigations on Dolichocephaly (Journal for Morphology and Anthropology, 1905).
