Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
61printed page
scan 113 of 568

61 But we can also eliminate another series of evidentiary documents beforehand, even if they surpass the last-mentioned ones in value. Woltmann investigated the physical type and the ancestry of Italians and Frenchmen who distinguished themselves as artists, hu- manists, natural scientists, philosophers, poets, and musicians, and found that the majority of them were to be assigned entirely or predominantly to the Germanic race. But the method is quite peculiar, how he claims more or less famous Italians, who had only blue eyes or others who had only blond hair, for the Germanic element. With the same justification, one could consider the former, because of their black hair, and the latter, because of their brown eyes, as belonging to the Mediterranean race. Even more uncertain is the connection of psychic characteristics with race or with specific racial traits. If someone has inherited only the eye color from the external characteristics of the blond race, why should he then owe all psychic characteristics to precisely this race, as Napoleon, precisely because of his blue eyes, is also supposed to have his genius from the Vandals? To name a few dozen names is not enough to say all men of importance were of Germanic descent. This school of thought generally attributes far too much weight to the hitherto most meager results of race research and, in its valuation of the Northern European race, adopts a thoroughly partisan standpoint (v. Neupauer). Since we have furthermore designated this section exclusively for the treatment of anthropological data material, we must reserve the critique of those theories that relate more to historico-philosophical themes and to the problem of heredity for the later parts of this book. In this section, we want to subject only the exact anthropolo- gical material to an analysis. One of the most important race theorists for the Jews, who stands more on historico- philosophical ground, namely Chamberlain, must therefore