Some believe that this development is a consequence of general historical and economic evolution, based on the cultures of the Orientals and the Romance peoples.
The others, however, stubbornly insist that it rests on the noble-race nature of the Germanic peoples, because only in their blood alone have the characteristics of the highest spiritual and mental perfection, namely ideality and genius, been implanted by nature "since time immemorial".
Without difficulty, however, proof can be furnished that it is completely false to claim that the Germanic peoples have always distinguished themselves through the possession (let alone, the sole possession) of brilliant talent and the noblest spiritual qualities. Let us therefore be permitted a very brief historical review:
According to Chamberlain, freedom and loyalty are the inherited basic traits of the Germanic character.
The Edda gives us the relatively oldest picture of Germanic views; but one would search in vain for loyalty as its focal point. It is well known that even the Germanic gods did not take oaths very seriously.
Also the historical picture that Felix Dahn, certainly no author biased against the Germanic peoples, draws of the character of these peoples in the first centuries of their appearance, is by no means an honorable one.
Whether the historian writes of Vandals, Ostrogoths or Visigoths, whether it be West-Germanics, Alemanni, Thuringians or Franks, Anglo-Saxons, Bavarians or Scandinavians — it is a gruesome report of lawlessness and bloodshed, an uninterrupted series of betrayals and acts of disloyalty, of regicides and family atrocities. Not one of the old Germanic rulers who ascended the throne without murdering a relative, not one who did not end through the treacherous betrayal of his closest relatives and friends. The historian's pen grows weary of writing down all the wickedness and baseness, all the spiritual lack of culture of these barbarian peoples. — Those were the true beginnings of the Germanic noble race. 29