— 5 —
hold. Similarly, numerous Jews, and not the worst among them, took up the gauntlet thrown down to them in the reproach of foreignness; they renounced for themselves the nationality that was being contested, and, with a feeling mixed of bitterness and pride, retreated, so to speak, into the sulking corner of National Judaism.
The Jewish-national question that arose in this way has been discussed multiple times and from the most varied standpoints: the ethnological, political, and economic. Some are enthusiastic about a national rebirth; others want nothing to do with the movement that aims for it. Where the former see salvation, the latter see an unfortunate aberration. But in the midst of the dispute that the parties are waging over the future fate of the Jews, the Jewish religion has been almost completely overlooked. Its vote, however, in all Jewish questions, and thus also here, should not merely be heard first, but should also be decisive. If, however, we introduce something into it, or mix it with something that does not accord with its spirit, indeed, that perhaps directly contradicts it, then we falsify it and inflict incalculable damage upon our spiritual property, for which the improvement of our external circumstances, as urgently desirable as it is, is bought too dearly. Not to mention that a treatment of Judaism according to the needs of the moment is unscientific. Such a symptomatic treatment, devoid of all diagnostic prerequisites and merely adapted to momentary needs, is and remains, however well-intentioned, quackery, and it can happen that in the intention to
