part of the masses—the middle, respectably honest part, the very same that, at the opportune moment, it will indeed be almost as easy to send to the barricades as to a pogrom. But this is precisely the mass that psychologically cannot bring itself to read brochures about Jewish virtues. It avidly reads a pro-pogrom brochure for the very same reason it avidly reads a revolutionary’s leaflet—if, of course, it is written in an understandable language: here, it is told of the causes of its own suffering; it is shown the means to alleviate its own misfortunes. The only difference is that the pro-pogrom brochure blames the Yid for everything, and the revolutionary leaflet—the police officer. But in both cases, it is addressed first and foremost not about Yids or police officers, but about itself, about its own vital interests. Anti-pogrom literature is a completely different matter. In its very purpose lies the absolute impossibility of its success: it is entirely devoted to proving precisely that Yids are in no way complicit in the sufferings of the Russian masses, that they are not to blame, that the cause does not lie with them—in a word, that for the Russian masses, the Jew is of no consequence. But then why on earth would it spend time reading about something that is of no consequence to it? Reading does not come easily to the mass man; he does not know how to “skim” the lines, he reads into them and absorbs their meaning. And this is precisely why he only picks up a booklet about which he knows for certain that herein—whether rightly or wrongly is another question—are explained the causes of his want and grief. He cannot, organically cannot, and in all conscience is not even obliged to be interested in some Jews as such. From the very moment they cease to be the cause of his misfortunes, they lose all interest for him. To tell him that this brochure proves the innocence of the Jews is to tell him that this brochure does not concern him. The Russian masses devour and will continue to devour pro-pogrom literature because it is literature about them, and they will not read anti-pogrom brochures because that is literature about Jews.
21