...poor, and that all the poor, be they Italians or Germans, should be as one? On the contrary, he called upon the rich and the poor to unite in the name of the patriotic idea, to forget all strife, to postpone all internal disputes until the moment the nationalistic ideal was realized.
Instead of striving for the democratization of the individual states that made up the Apennine peninsula in his day, he forced an entire generation, casting aside other, perhaps more important social concerns, to devote all its strength to the nationalistic and, in essence, senseless task—the creation of a unified kingdom. Why? What a whim? Was this really necessary for the happiness of the people? Does it not matter to the poor folk how many kings are over them? Would it not have been better for the people if Garibaldi had directed his efforts in another direction, and now on the Apennine peninsula there were several republics instead of one kingdom? In essence, if one looks closely into the very depths of it, was not Garibaldi's life a mistake from beginning to end? Did he not confuse, did he not lead a whole people, a whole generation, astray from the straight path, and—worse yet—did he not bequeath his delusions to other peoples and to later generations?
Is it not by his example and his successes that the chauvinists of the whole world are now carried away, is it not in Italy's footsteps that they now follow, screaming about the necessity of national states and delaying the resolution of the social problem? And if one reconstructs in all its details that atmosphere which reigned in Italy during the era of the struggle for independence, in the era of the expulsion of the Germans and the unification of the peninsula, and if one properly delves into this atmosphere, full of nationalistic fervor, saturated with hatred for the foreigner, resounding with the intolerable declamation of patriotic slogans; if one recalls that for whole decades everything else was forgotten and abandoned: no one thought of schools, of the development of industry and trade, even of good laws, and all efforts were absorbed exclusively by questions of nationality and patriotism,—if all this
182