One cannot completely dispossess the unfortunate tribe. One must at least leave it some goods with which it could trade.
According to Dostoevsky, he sees the ruin of Russia in the Zhid. This, it would seem, gave the Zhids a certain right to attention; however, there is not a single complete Jewish character in Dostoevsky's work, as far as I can recall now. But if it is true that a beaten man is glad when his neighbor is beaten too, then we can console ourselves by recalling Dostoevsky's Polish types, especially in The Karamazovs and The Gambler. The 'little Pole' is invariably something vile, sycophantic, and cowardly, while at the same time ridiculous and insolent; and even those hopes concealed in the Polish soul, which their most sworn enemy ought to treat with respect, about which Bülow himself, while defending a law hostile to the Poles, recently spoke in the Reichstag with his hat in his hands—it is sickening to recall with what bilious saliva these hopes of a crushed people are covered by the subtle, long-suffering author of The Karamazovs.
Chekhov? Jewish critics are terribly fond of quoting a phrase dropped in passing from "My Life," that "the library of the provincial town would be empty, were it not for the young ladies and young Jews." This deeply moves the Jewish critics, it flatters them greatly; they see in it a clear agitation for the unrestricted admission of Jews to education. We are a kind people, and our kindest trait is that we are content with little.... In essence, however, Chekhov was an observer who knew neither pity nor anger, and who loved nothing except the fading beauty of "the cherry orchard"; therefore, the Jewish figures occasionally found in "The Steppe," "Tumbleweed," "Ivanov," are written with this artist's usual truthful indifference. And with the same truthful indifference, Chekhov drew his Ivanov, one of the countless Ivanovs who constitute the fund of the Russian intelligentsia, and with the same truthful indifference testified that Ivanov, when in a bad mood, is fully capable of berat-
127
