Theodor Fritsch · Handbook of the Jewish Question · 1944
195printed page
scan 196 of 339

the basis of a universally present, great "artistic" skill, the two main schisms and directions of Jewish art and lifestyle: the one turned toward the soul, "inclined to asceticism," the other subject to the body, championing sensuousness and sensuality. To the first direction belong only a few Jews: Mahler, who in tragic entanglement "wanted to force the connection with the German musical spirit, which was simply denied to him by blood" (Eichenauer), furthermore Schönberg and this and that smaller, today forgotten modernist; to the other, however, from Mendelssohn (whose undeniable creative conflict is little visible under the smoothing veneer of intellect and education), Meyerbeer and Offenbach, the genuine Jewish mocker, Lezzanin, on and downward the many hundreds of kitsch and trash composers of the 19th century, the operetta daubers of the 20th and their willing helpers, the journalists and critics. What then just barely emerges as original merit from the great names under this spell is mercilessly revealed in the smaller and smallest ones either as technically skilled imitation and cleverly whitewashed epigonism (E. W. Korngold, Kletzki, Raphael, Wellesz, Gal) or as puffed-up kitsch (Lassen, Gumbert, Goldmark, Brüll) or as time-bound superficial participation in every stylistic sensation (Toch and, in a larger format, Weill). Whereby it is still more sympathetic when this or that Jew, rarely enough, once confesses to his race and tries to write music out of its folk character: Ernest Bloch, Wilhelm Grosz, furthermore stylistically also Schönberg (the Sprechgesang of "Pierrot lunaire" rooted in the synagogue) and Mahler (cf. Moser's and Eichenauer's interesting evidence), and earlier Offenbach and Goldmark.

As said, the gates to the European cultural world were opened, Moses Mendelssohn, the composer's grandfather, fought for social integration with tireless effort, - the German Jew (and soon also citizen) was born. From now on, he begins to become the "effective ferment of national decomposition" (Mommsen). The racial mixing and thus "disordering" of the German spirit began; the spiritual aimlessness of German Romanticism, for example, as Eichenauer proves, did not spring from a Nordic search for new territory, but from an aimless and rootless groping arising from racial mixture. Like mushrooms after the rain, whole generations of Jewish musicians of all shades now shoot up at the turn of the 18th to the 19th century: Meyerbeer and Herold in 1791, Moscheles in 1794, the music writer A. B. Marx in 1795, Halévy in 1799; the fashionable pianist Herz in 1803, the pianists Benedict and Fischhof in 1804, the singers Grisi in 1805 and 1811; Mendelssohn in 1809, the violinist Ferd. David in 1810, Ferd. Hiller in 1811, Sig. Thalberg in 1812, the violinist Ernest in 1814; only a little later then the manufacturer of kitsch songs Ferd. Gumbert in 1818 and Offenbach in 1819.

But this was only the beginning! The social penetration of the German bourgeois-intellectual salons with Jewish participants, especially in the days of the literary Romantics who were instinctless in this regard (the Schlegel brothers, furthermore also the circle around Zelter and later the liberal-aesthetic one around Liszt), was gradually followed by an equal penetration of the entire public music life, whereby the Jews benefited from their tenacious will to live, their unscrupulous persistence, and their astonishing tribal loyalty (instinct for patronage). In all areas of musical cultivation, representatives of the Jewish race established themselves, patronized each other, and thus made their advancement more and more easy. It became in fact as Frederick William IV once expressed it: > "The insolent mob daily lays the ax to the root of the German essence through word, writing, and image." The first pedagogues: besides Mendelssohn, the already mentioned, quite meritorious Marx, then the theorist Jadassohn, the violinists Joachim and David; the first composers: again, alongside and after Mendelssohn, Ignaz Brüll, Goldmark, the

  • 195 -