Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 43 · 26 October 1906
7printed page
scan 5 of 24

No. 43. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)

…not the slightest thing to do; it is purely economic in nature, and the members act wisely if they do not make a principle of the isolation forced upon them by circumstances, but endeavour in this respect to adapt themselves to circumstances with all speed. Otherwise they fall, with logical necessity, into economic ruin.

For the native Jews, however, such organisations are pointless, for their interests are bound up a thousandfold with those of their surroundings and in just as many cases conflict with those of their Jewish associates. What, after all, does economic-national mean? It means fostering, on national grounds, the economic interest of one's fellow-nationals. That is, of necessity, opening an economic struggle against those who are not of the nation. Does Dr. Mühsam really believe that this is a thing to be striven for in Germany, or that anyone at all will follow him along this path? Dr. Mühsam wishes in this way to stem the "mass misery." Does it really exist in Germany? Thank God, no; and so one ought not to forge plans for removing it.

The same holds for his plan to raise the Jews culturally. Should that really be possible through a German national-Jewish party? Does he wish to combat our lofty German culture and to put a national one in its place? And which? He wishes to educate full Jews. Surely not by making Hebrew the language of the German Jews, or by advocating a complete social seclusion?! The former is a Utopia in a land whose Jews live so scattered that even Jewish schools are possible only in a few large cities; and social seclusion would mean the formation of a state within the state, of a kernel indigestible to the community as a whole, which would needs lead to violent opposition from the rest of the population, bring the Jews themselves into an intolerable position, and exclude them from every political participation.

Yet this alone is precisely what can help us to an improvement of our position. Only we are nowhere strong enough to elect deputies by our own strength, as Dr. Mühsam wishes. We should always have to make compacts. And now let one imagine a party of economic seclusion with a Jewish-national-cultural programme. And of such a party Dr. Mühsam seriously expects that anyone should consider it fit for an alliance! Thus are our representatives to enter the parliaments! That is possible only if the Jews are induced to bring their weight to bear within the several rival parties.

We must face the political parties with demands; as a party of our own we are impossible. The Eastern Jews are not better than we, and have not "proudly and boldly" preserved their individuality; rather, they live in a culturally lower milieu and in dense masses, and therefore under other political conditions. Not morality but the facts determine their attitude, as they do ours.

We are in the position of Danton, who said: "I grew up among gentlemen of rank. On finishing my studies I possessed nothing and could become nothing, being without ancestors or patrons. My old comrades turned their backs on me. The régime forced us into opposition by having us educated without opening a career to our abilities."

They opened the public schools and the universities to us, they summoned us to become modern men — and when we did so, they turned their backs on us and laughed at us. Thus — exactly as among the middle classes before 1848 — there arose the "problematic natures," the half-men who have no ground beneath their feet and are cut loose from the old tradition. The spiritually homeless. For all of them the return to the old people was salvation. And now, out of gratitude and in the happiness of having ground beneath them once more, they would do everything for this people and believe they can accomplish everything with it. But in this they overlook the distribution of forces, the means of power. It cannot be done. What is possible in Austria or Russia is for that very reason not practicable with us.

And in future it is best to keep silent about plans that are impracticable and of no use, and that must make our surroundings our adversaries on economic grounds and the governments on cultural grounds. Moreover, we have overcome our internal differences with difficulty enough, truly, and ought not without need to give fresh occasion for internal strife.

DR. A. FRIEDEMANN

*) The author is in error if he supposes that the editors of the central organ have not the right of free critical consideration with regard to the Landsmannschaften. We must, moreover, observe that we are not in a position to identify ourselves with the foregoing remarks, which, in spite of many correct observations, rest in our opinion, in their premises and conclusions, upon arbitrary subjective assumptions. We shall, moreover, return both to the foregoing article and to the remarks of Dr. Kassel and Dr. Mühsam, for whose contents we likewise leave the responsibility to the authors, after the close of the discussion. The Editors.


FROM THE BEZALEL

Our Jerusalem correspondent J. K. writes to us:

The news that the Cologne Annual Conference has granted the "Bezalel" a loan from the resources of the National Fund for the purchase of a site suited to the purposes of the institution and the building of a spacious edifice was received here with great joy. One sees in it not only the full sympathy of the Zionists for the aims of the "Bezalel," but rejoices just as much that the Annual Conference has thereby expressed its gratitude to the head of the institution, Professor Boris Schatz. With this grant the Actions Committee has cleared out of the way the greatest obstacle to a prosperous development of the institute, and it remains only to wish that the occasional or annual subventions which have hitherto flowed to the "Bezalel" from various quarters may yet increase considerably in all places and in all circles. May our friends in the Diaspora make it their ambition to agitate everywhere for the "Bezalel" and to further it materially! Then, as one may say even today, we shall obtain in the land a true model institution, which will bring not only work and livelihood to the Jewish inhabitants but honour to all the Jews of the world.

The "Bezalel," beside its chief purpose, the improvement of the state of labour and industry in Palestine, makes it its concern to work also for the deepening and cultivation of the Jewish spirit. The pupils of the "Bezalel," together with some respected persons here, have founded a society under the name of "Deborah," which, on the occasion of a teachers' assembly, all the teachers resolved to support. This society has the task of supporting poor pupils of the "Bezalel," arranging art exhibitions, establishing drawing courses, and taking part in artistic publications.

During the holidays some 47 teachers, men and women, from all Palestine, and even from Syria, assembled in the girls' school at Jaffa, where Prof. Schatz, with the help of his pupils, gave them instruction in drawing. It was heart-warming to see how our teachers, old and young, sat down once more upon the school bench, bent their backs and for five

2*