Page 10. — "Die Welt" — No. 42.
(continued from page 9)
...their distinctive character and joined the political groups of their fatherland which had set themselves the goal of changing the social order and the form of government. One may well assert today, after nearly a hundred years of assimilationist endeavours, that this manner of solving the Jewish question has gone absolutely bankrupt. But the other path, too — as things stand today — may be regarded as impassable within any foreseeable time. Even if the complete social emancipation of the Jews in Russia, Roumania, Persia, etc., is achieved, it is to be expected that the oppression of the Jews hitherto sanctioned by law will become one carried on by the instincts of the people, and that at best a social Jewish distress will develop, as was the case in the West. The best proof of the impossibility of a harmonious co-operation of all the discontented, nationally diverse elements is furnished by the socialist organisation of Russia itself. The diversity of interests and of national character caused the Lettish, Polish, Armenian and Jewish organisations to emerge from the originally uniform mass. And this separation is not a merely external one, but one of principle, so that difficulties have already come to light more than once in action planned in common. The splitting-off of the "Bund" from the Social Democratic organisation in Russia, which stands programmatically on the same ground, is the best proof of the distinctive character of Jewish interests, which are determined neither by territorial nor by economic boundaries, but rest upon the specific national character peculiar to the Jewish people as such. This recognition was bound to lead to uniting the Jews in their entirety for the common solution of the Jewish distress, to organising them without regard to the frontiers of countries from the "völkisch" standpoint. So arose the inter-territorial national Jewish movement, whose political goal is represented by the Zionist programme.
The Zionist programme, which is a historical necessity, represents the radical and universal solution of the Jewish question. That is to say, when it is fulfilled, the Jewish distress will have ceased to exist. It is, like all political programmes, a programme for the future and is not in itself a means of immediate help. This deficiency a movement newly arisen within Zionism, Territorialism, seeks to remedy by a new or supplementary political programme. Since this tendency sees the cause of the impossibility of rapid help in the question of the land, it strikes Palestine more or less radically out of the Zionist programme.
I will refrain from discussing the point that no country in the world is able to give us a contiguous territory which by its size and its fitness for cultivation would suffice for the Jewish people for a more distant future, or even only for its present needs; and that a plurality of Jewish state-formations at various points of the globe would be of no service to us. Our misfortune, which results from our dispersion, would by a new form of dispersion perhaps take on another shape, but would certainly not be removed. — The crux of the matter is that the immediate taking-up of such territories as offer themselves to us can, for many years to come, hardly bring about any perceptible decrease of the distress. The internal ordering of a new state, its fitting into the outside world, the creation of markets for its products, in short its entire development within and without, can proceed only quite gradually; thereby, however, the endeavour of the Territorialists, who hope for a rapid removal of the frightful misery, becomes illusory.
The present distress can be relieved only by an economic programme, not by a political one. The economic programme for the present forms the necessary complement of our political programme for the future.
It is clear that the economic programme must bear a varying stamp according to the country in which it is to be applied. The constitution, the economy, the general level of culture on the one side, the kind of Jewish distress and the territorially differing interests of the Jews on the other, shape the demands differently. The goal everywhere is the economic and cultural elevation of the Jews. Just as we have come to know the united co-operation of all as the precondition for attaining our political goal, so our next task in the economic field will be the gathering and organisation of all Jews within the various spheres of interest. In this we rely upon the excellently carried-out Zionist organisation. Within the centres so created, tasks of three kinds will have to be fulfilled. 1. The setting-up of demands common to all, 2. The setting-up of special demands for the individual associations of interest, 3. The maintenance of connection with one another and with the political organisation.
-
The demands common to all will aim at the removal of existing legal or customary restrictions upon the Jews, at the raising of the general level of culture, of the physical condition, etc. This department will have to concern itself with emigration in general, and to regulate its direction and its conduct. In short, all those factors which share in the specific distress of the whole Jewry of a country will have to be taken into account by this department. — It is clear that these tasks will in many cases coincide with those of already existing Jewish or party-political groups in the country. The prospect of their being carried out will therefore be increased, and a rapprochement will be initiated which can only be of advantage to our political goal as well.
-
The creation of sub-groups will have to proceed essentially from economic points of view. These sub-groups will be brought together by community of occupational interests, and they will furnish the foundation of the great organisation. The joining of Jewish artisans, workers or tradesmen to existing national or Social Democratic associations has throughout not proved its worth. The Jewish character, which in economic life indisputably stands out as a specific one, requires also specifically Jewish organs of protection. Moreover there exists a series of external factors which do not touch the interests of associations organised on another basis, but are of great influence upon the economic life of the Jews.
Nevertheless there will of course be a series of tasks which they are able to solve together with economic associations differently composed.
To this department would belong in particular also organisations of Jewish immigrants. Their community of interest lies in the difficulty of acquiring a foreign culture and in unfamiliarity with the customs of the country. It may be of interest to mention here that such an organisation has arisen, among other places, in Berlin too. Jewish immigrants have joined together in a society ("Jüdischer Volksverein") which is to make it easier for its members to get on in their new fatherland. It seeks to attain its goal, with regard to the particular course of development of the immigrants, by cultural (courses of instruction, etc.) and economic (labour exchange, etc.) means.
It is to be expected that these purely Jewish economic associations will preserve for our people a number of capable forces which would otherwise have been absorbed by other organisations, or which would have gone under.
- The third department is to be regarded as the direction of the entire organisation. It is clear that only an orderly working-together of all the groups affords prospect of success. And it is likewise clear that this economic programme, which is to be a complement of our political one, may in no case be opposed to the interests of the latter. —
In essence the advantages of an economic complement to our political programme will be the following:
The combating of Jewish distress is begun at once, and indeed on a scale and by a path which — so far as it is possible at all to treat the symptoms — meets the mass misery most effectively.
The Jewish sufferers are preserved to us as Jews.
The Jewish mass is organised and learns to rely upon its own strength. It learns to know the value of unity and discipline and becomes conscious of its strength.
The measure of general education and the national prosperity is raised.
In this way an essential preparatory work is accomplished for our political plan for the future. Serviceable whole Jews are brought up. But a calmer working-together in the spirit of our Basle Programme, which we have recognised as alone correct, is also assured — a programme which runs the danger of being altered out of regard for the present misery."
* * *
Meanwhile the year that has since elapsed has proved the views developed above right. In Russia and in Austria Jewish-national parties of the country have arisen, which have demanded their representation in Parliament. Now it is objected to us that the number of Jews living in Germany is too small, and that they live too scattered among the rest of the population, for them anywhere to have a prospect of electing their candidate. Moreover there actually seems to prevail in thoroughly national circles the apprehension that by the exercise of our national solidarity within the German frontiers we should violate our duties as German citizens. The common interest