Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 35 · 31 August 1906
9printed page
scan 9 of 24

No. 35. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.

(continued from page 8)

...insisted in any case that the remainder of the money should now be put to use at once.

Ussischkin declares that the inner A. C. had at the time expressly entrusted the disposal of the relief funds to the committee of the Russian A. C. members, because it held the view that the Russian gentlemen were the best placed to find the right form of help and to supervise the use of the money. It was, moreover, an altogether mistaken view on Mr. Cowen's part to call it so great an error that the funds had not yet all been used. The President of the E. A. C. had expressly emphasised to the committee of the Russian A. C. members that the relief action of the Zionists must bear a different character from the customary one of the societies. The Zionists had insisted again and again that the mere giving of money was not the right kind of help. The Russian A. C. members had therefore deliberated upon another mode of relief and had arrived at definite resolutions. It had first been resolved to found information bureaus in the East out of a part of the sum, and no one could deny that such a use afforded an exceedingly valuable help to those who had suffered by the pogroms. He need hardly point out how enormously emigration had grown through the pogroms, how in particular emigration to the East had increased under their influence, and to what terrible sufferings, privations and disappointments the mass of emigrants was exposed who, without sufficient information, took up the wanderer's staff without plan or aim. From the remainder of the money it was proposed to build an orphanage for such children as had lost their parents through the pogroms. Upon this proposal the Annual Conference would have to decide.

Dr. Schmarja Levin complains bitterly of the distrust which the directors showed towards the Russian A. C. members in this matter. With the small sum that had stood at the Zionists' disposal, naturally not very much could be done, which is why he had from the outset declared a special relief work of the Zionists to be inappropriate. Had these few funds been given directly to the sufferers, as Mr. Cowen wishes, it would not have been possible thereby to extend the relief work undertaken by the united committees, which had over 10,000,000 marks at their disposal. It was an altogether mistaken view on Mr. Cowen's part to see relief merely in the dispensing of alms. That the money had not yet been wholly applied to its purpose was neither an error nor anything unusual. The united relief societies, too, had by no means used up all their contributions, since they proceeded on the correct view that distress does not show itself everywhere at once, but that the actual damage can only be ascertained in the course of time. For the Russian A. C. members the matter was completely settled. They had received a mandate and had taken their decisions. If objection were now to be raised against them, the committee would know how to draw the consequences.

Mr. Sokolow likewise points out to Mr. Cowen that it is wrong to suppose that relief after such a catastrophe could consist only in feeding the hungry, clothing the naked and tending the wounded. The real misfortune only shows itself later. Moreover, a relief action had never yet been managed otherwise by others either, and after Kishineff the Russian Jews themselves had come to the bureaus of the relief societies with the request that the money collected should on no account be distributed at once. Such relief could only make the misfortune still greater. We have, besides, no reason whatever to regard the matter critically. If any quarter does indeed draw material against Zionism from this affair, that is of no consequence whatever. In this case it is merely a matter of attacks from the Territorialist side, and it is well known to be one of the chief occupations of certain gentlemen to forge weapons against Zionism, no matter where the material for them is taken from.

Mr. Kann stated: The E. A. C. did, it is true, leave the distribution of the funds to the Russian A. C. members. But it proceeded on the self-evident assumption that the manner of their use would always keep within the bounds of the relief work. The intended establishment of information bureaus or of other indirect undertakings meant to support the Jews against the pogroms is certainly not in the spirit of the donors, who, at least so far as I am able to survey the situation, gave their contributions for a direct work of relief. In any case we must come to a clear decision on their use and carry it out without delay. If the Russian gentlemen are not able to do so, the money is to be returned to the Trust, which will surely find ways and means of effecting the distribution in the spirit of the donors.

From the further debate, in which Messrs. Dr. Katzenelson, Wolffsohn, Dr. Tschlenow, Scheinkin and Cowen took part, it emerges that there is no longer any difference of opinion concerning the funds already used. Concerning the use of the remainder still in hand, the following resolution was passed at a later sitting: The A. C. is to inquire in what form this fund can be employed on behalf of the victims of the pogroms in Palestine.

(Close of the morning sitting at half past two.)

Afternoon Sitting.

Opening at half past four.

Dr. A. Marmorek moves the following resolution: 1. To recommend to the inner A. C. that, in disputes between members of the Zionist movement which arise out of Zionist activity, it should endeavour, as far as possible, to induce the parties concerned to appeal to the Congress Court. 2. To lay before the next Congress a motion extending the powers of the Congress Court to the disputes mentioned under 1. as well. The speaker supports his motion at some length by pointing to the disputes that have recently occurred in England and Austria, which are calculated to injure the standing of our movement and to loosen party discipline.

Dr. Schalit opposes Dr. Marmorek's remarks and emphatically rejects the reasons adduced with regard to Austria.

Dr. Marmorek's motion is carried by 17 votes to 6.

In connection with these discussions the President emphasised that he considered it as inadmissible as it was unjust for a society to call upon a member of the A. C., for whatever reasons, to resign. The members of the A. C. are elected by the confidence of the Congress and are responsible to the Congress alone.

Thereupon the Chairman of the Palestine Commission, Professor Dr. Warburg, delivered, to lively applause, the

Report of the Palestine Commission

The activity of the Commission for the Exploration of Palestine has moved during the past year in roughly the same paths as in the preceding period under report.

We must distinguish:

  1. Research of a scientific and economic nature;

  2. Work for the spread of knowledge of Palestine;

  3. Organising work for the development of Palestine in cultural and economic respects;

  4. Advisory activity towards the Actions Committee, the federations, the local groups and individuals;

  5. Administration of Zionist and other institutions.

  6. As regards research, it was above all the knowledge of the geology of Palestine that was further advanced. As is known, in the year 1904 Messrs. Dr. Blanckenhorn and Agronowa Aaronsohn, on our commission, had made the region of the Dead Sea the subject of thorough investigations which yielded important results. These investigations were continued in the year under report, and chiefly parts of northern and eastern Palestine were travelled through. The exceptionally wet weather of the winter, on the other hand, prevented the geological survey of the Jordan valley, which had likewise been planned, and which must accordingly be postponed to a future year.

Since Dr. Blanckenhorn had received a very considerable contribution towards his journey from the Royal Prussian Academy of Science, we had only to bear the cost of the journey of Mr. Aaronsohn, who was already staying in Palestine, and who not only rendered important services on this expedition through his general knowledge of conditions in Palestine, but also collected valuable material, particularly in botanical and agricultural respects.

Further, the Commission also arranged for an expert survey of the water resources of the Jordan valley; in the