8 — "Die Welt" — No. 34
The Russian revolutionary parties are well aware that the strength of a proletarian party lies in the trade union, which gives it the means of influencing the economic life of the country and the course of political events. In the early days, too, every party created trade unions on its own account. The "Bund" did so as well. Now a united trade-union organisation is to emerge from the chaos. True to the principles of Social Democracy, all the parties demand a trade-union organisation embracing all workmen, without distinction of nation or of party allegiance. The "Bund," too, demands it in its resolutions approved by the VIIth Conference. But it also points to the danger of an anarchist "syndicalism" and demands a constant contact between party and trade union. In order to render the relations of the two institutions more cordial, various means, mostly of a technical nature, are proposed. The word — national sections — also occurs in the resolution. But no more than the word. What the "Bund" understands by it (what, after all, is a "national section" in the trade union? — national trade unions, similar to the form of organisation demanded by the Czech Social Democrats in Austria, are, of course, rejected by the Bundists) remains as unclear as all the other "national enunciations" of the Bund. In practice the word "section" will presumably be so interpreted that the "Bund" will not permit even the trade-union combination of all Jewish workmen, but will simply found "Bundist" trade unions, which must turn over a part of their contributions to its party treasury. With the entry of the "Bund" into the "Party," this golden age, too, will be over. The "Party" will make clear to the Bund the meaning of the demand for a "non-party" trade union (as if such existed on the Continent!) and will without doubt enforce the surrender of all Bundist foundations into the general Empire-wide federations. The Bundist workmen will be withdrawn, in the trade-union sphere even more than in the political, from the sphere of action of the "Bund," and subjected to the Moscow or St. Petersburg central office. The sole mistress of the trade union and of the Empire-wide federations will remain the Russian "Party," against which the "Bund" will be in no position to set an economic organisation of its own. By its entry into the "Party," the "Bund" renounces the strongest backbone of a proletarian group. Its influence upon the Jewish working class and within the "Party" itself will gradually sink to freezing-point. Only if the Russian "Party" should lose power and prestige through eventual failures could the "Bund" succeed, at the cost of the Party's weakness, in attaining influence within the party organisation, though not permanently.
The "hard" Bundist "Nay-sayers" seem to foresee this, or at least to suspect it. They reproach their "soft" party comrades with being under the spell of the "Iskra-Zionist agitation"! But however warlike and valiant both sides may bear themselves, even if they would represent their capitulation to the "Party" to the simple as a success, — they will not succeed in deceiving the observer. The new stage of development upon which the "Bund" is preparing to enter is that of slow dissolution.
THE VIth GENERAL MEETING OF THE PALESTINE SOCIETY (CHOWEWE-ZION) IN ODESSA *)
In the absence of the President, Herr Abraham Grünberg, the VIth Meeting was opened by Dr. G. J. Himmelfarb, who also delivered the report for the last 3 years. He stated that, in view of the general situation in Russia and especially of the Jews, the receipts of these years had fallen off considerably, a circumstance which had the consequence that the Committee was not in a position fully to carry out the resolutions of the Vth General Meeting. On the other hand, the activity of the Committee was further hampered by the fact that the expenditures had been fixed by percentage by the previous General Meeting. "But since we happened not to be in a position," declares Dr. Himmelfarb, "to manage in these 3 years precisely as was laid down, we have closed with a deficit of over 9000 Rbl., while over 18 000 Rbl. lie untouched in the treasury because we could buy no land." He therefore asks the General Meeting to permit these 18 000 Rbl. to be transferred to the assets, and so to discharge the Committee for its not exact execution of the resolutions.
The Meeting grants the Committee its discharge and elects the following presidium: Ussischkin as chairman, Ludwipol, Triwus and Schwarzmann as secretaries.
Ussischkin greets the delegates who have arrived from all over Russia and announces that word came in from many that they could not leave home because of the imminent railway strike. This, he says, also explains the small number of delegates from outside (85) **). Moreover, the panic that prevails everywhere must also be taken into account. Ussischkin then introduces the forthcoming debates on the report and on the tactics of the committee to be newly elected for the next 3 years with roughly the following words, given here in summary: The Palestine Society was founded by Pinsker for the purpose of furthering the regeneration of the Jewish people. That was the idea which lay at the basis of our Society. Unfortunately, however, this Society was too one-sided. The Chowewe-Zion hoped to obtain Palestine through colonisation alone. Everything else they held superfluous. The consequence was that Chowewe-Zionism sank to Rachmones-Zionism, to philanthropy, because those who had already been settled there could not be abandoned. The best of the Chowewe-Zion fell into despair and thought their cause was lost. Then, 8 or 9 years ago, a mighty organisation — the Zionist — was created, which rested upon precisely the same idea — the regeneration of the Jewish people. And if misunderstandings often arose between the two currents, it was not the final aim that was to blame, but the method of execution. The Palestine Committee thought to conquer through practical work in Palestine. Life showed that something else is needed as well, and that is what constitutes the principle of political Zionism. In the end, however, matters came so far that the two currents almost united, the VIth Congress creating the Palestine Commission, while the VIIth Congress recognised practical work in Palestine.
The first word on general tactics goes to Dr. Raimist, who proposes that the Committee should concern itself in the next 3 years only with schools and information, for which purpose it should go hand in hand with other analogous societies. A far-reaching activity with great plans he holds impracticable for want of money.
Thereupon the aged representative of Chowewe-Zionism, Herr Lilienblum, speaks: The misfortune of the Palestine Committee is that we occupy ourselves with philanthropy, that large points of view have remained remote from us. That is the secret of our poverty. When we created this Society and had far-reaching plans of regeneration in view, our receipts in two months were as large as they now are in a year (54000 roubles). If we adopt the Raimist motion, we remain with the old policy of philanthropy and sink to a large Talmud Torah society. We must occupy ourselves with the purchase of land. Only a far-reaching programme can bring our budget back to its old level and make it much greater still.
Drujanow takes the standpoint of Raimist and stresses that it would be ridiculous to wish to carry out great plans with these small means. We must express our warmest thanks to the Committee for having succeeded, with this
*) We reserve the right to return to the Meeting, of which we received the present special report before the paper went to press. **) Apart from the participants from Odessa.