Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 22 · 1 June 1906
11printed page
scan 7 of 18

"Die Welt"

(continued from page 10)

…the outside they are chiefly a policy of colonisation; towards the inside, the consolidation of the party and the strengthening of the Jewish nation. Both directions are intimately bound up with each other and cannot be separated.

"Propaganda," on the other hand, detached from the whole, is petty and small even in its conception and not at all suited to the present situation. Insofar, moreover, as the ordinary flavour of puffery still clings to it, it may become not only mistaken but harmful as well. Our only power of attraction towards the outside can be our inner strength. The first flourishing colony, the first real successes in Palestine, have certainly brought us infinitely more adherents than numerous laborious propaganda meetings. The right party tactics must heed the natural course of development, must wait until a thing is fully ripened; they must hold to the principle: Natura non facit saltum. Propaganda, on the contrary, set up as a detached task, follows the method of acting à tout prix; it must do violence to the things that serve it only as means.

It is quite natural that the work of enlightenment about Zionism is not thereby to be done away with. It is likewise self-evident that only the directives can proceed from the central leadership, while the executive organs are the several local authorities, upon whom the strengthening of the party, the conquest of positions of power in Jewry within their local bounds devolves, as they must in general always be willing organs in the service of party policy.


On the Latest Balance-Sheet of the Jewish Colonial Bank

By Dr. ISAK STRAUS and ERNST GOITEIN (Heidelberg)

Dear Sirs,

The success of our practical work is minimal — so one hears complaints on every side to-day, precisely in thoroughly Zionist circles — and men cast about for new ways which, now that the old ones are beginning to fail, are to supply new means for the far-reaching aims. All these new suggestions are to be welcomed if they hold within them the possibility of even a narrowly limited success; but alongside them one should try to breathe new and more bountiful life into those great institutions of Zionism, to snatch them from the lethargy in which the life that at first pulsed so freshly seems to be ebbing away. With the success of the Colonial Bank the eventual practical fulfilment of our Zionist plans stands or falls; the Bank will either be able to raise the great means for its mighty aims, or it will not be capable of it, that is, it will never form that factor of power in economic and thereby in political life which alone will enable it to draw successfully nearer to the final goal. And now we see a steady decline of newly accruing cash precisely in this most important institution. Whereas Theodor Herzl, after quite other sums had first been contemplated, finally set two million £ as a minimum, we see to-day, with a paid-up capital of about £ 250000, the further sale of shares already almost drying up. Whereas in the year 1902 altogether 19000 shares were sold, this figure sinks in 1903 to 6000, in 1904 to not quite 3000, and for 1905 and the first quarter of 1906 together it is shown by the management of the Bank at scarcely 2000. Thus a constant, rapid decline. Manifold reasons have been adduced to explain it; here we shall concern ourselves only with the most significant, and one seldom yet emphasised sharply enough. The public, the great capitalist as well as the small, buys bank shares as an investment of capital (speculation does not interest us here); for that purpose it naturally chooses such securities as, under sound management, offer a good return. The latter has hitherto not been the case with the Jewish Colonial Bank, which has so far been able only twice to distribute a dividend of up to 2 1/2 %, and thereby its shares drop out of the ranks of those suitable for investment. Be it noted, this holds even for the most zealous Zionist, who as a small capitalist cannot forgo the yield of his income, and as a great capitalist will not. What consequences this has for the sale of shares is clearly to be seen from the figures given above. They show how far our Bank will get if it founds its further development solely upon the good Jewish heart, which every year will still buy a few hundred shares from it à fond perdu.

If this dangerous standstill is to be avoided henceforth, if our shares are to find a sale, then an attempt must be made to induce Jewish, or at least Zionist, capital to use the shares of the J. C. Trust for investment just as it uses those of other soundly managed banks, and for that higher returns are needed.

Now it is far from our intention to give the management, which has hitherto been able to lay before us such meagre interest results, advice from the green table concerning the details of the business. What is to be criticised here is solely the principles that have hitherto been decisive for the Bank's activity, and which precisely the newly published balance-sheet as at 31st March 1906 once again brings so clearly to light. Put briefly and simply: the activity of our Bank does not rest solely upon purely commercial principles. The Jewish Colonial Bank arose upon other ground than other joint-stock undertakings of a purely business kind; its aims, laid down in its articles, are not guided solely by commercial considerations; but its management to-day should and may have solely a sound business tendency. Such an institution cannot and may not spend a sum of more than a third of its net annual earnings on an object of philanthropy, however weighty (an outlay which this year will probably make the distribution of a dividend impossible for it). Thousands will thereby have had bread for an hour, and hundreds of thousands, if this principle continues to serve as the guiding rule, will have to languish permanently.

No banking undertaking to-day will invest a considerable part of its capital in English Consols merely in order always to have the money lying ready for an operation that may possibly serve its purposes. At every moment to-day the point is to have one's capital invested profitably; only so can adequate annual returns be obtained. And that everything depends on this precisely in the case of our Bank is surely as clear as day. If the Colonial Bank is one day to be well equipped for the success for which the Zionists all over the world are working with such great self-sacrifice, it must stand forth as a first-class banking institution, in its management as in its returns, long beforehand. With the few hundred or thousand shares that it still sells every year it will never be able to achieve that. Our Bank, moreover, should not live upon the philanthropic moods of its people, and will never grow strong on them; for that quite other factors are needed, far mightier in their efficacy.

Thus it is the tendency that must change, but whose change also promises quite certain success. For why should our Bank succeed less than dozens of other similarly capitalised undertakings in attaining relatively quickly to a proper, regular annual balance? Especially as it is protected from all too speculative undertakings by a management so warmly and ideally interested in its office. But the whole endeavour must be directed towards soon attaining a return, moderate if need be, yet steady, on the basis of a purely commercial conduct of business. Then, and only then, will it be possible to win at least Zionist capital for the Bank on a larger scale.


A Jewish Orphanage in Palestine

Dear Sir,

The Central Office of the Russian members of the A. C. has proposed to use Frs. 100.000 from the Russian relief fund for the establishment of an orphanage in Palestine, for children orphaned by the pogroms. Against the proposal in and for itself not only is there nothing to object; it is, rather, to be warmly welcomed. It is an outflow of the old Zionist idea that almsgiving alone does not suffice; it endeavours to lend the work of relief a lasting significance. Doubtless the Frs. 100.000, had they been distributed at once, would have done much good; the hungry would have been fed, the naked clothed. But 100.000 Frs. is a very small sum; it would have vanished in the sea of misery that roared about us. Now, however, a very few are to be helped completely; they are to be given not merely bread for to-day and to-morrow, they are to be rescued and led to a new and happier life. And children they are to be! Not yet broken by the weight of misfortune, young shoots that wait only for better soil in order to grow strong, healthy and blooming.

But how do we mean to work? From 100.000 Frs. no orphanage can be built. I may well assume that this