"Die Welt" — No. 5.
(continued from page 7)
…higher is than that of the peasants, a soldiery which at any hour, at the word of command, shoots down its own brothers like sparrows, a court camarilla fighting for its existence, that is, for the raisin-cakes which it is atavistically accustomed to devour at the people's expense; . . . between these elements 5 million Jews, wedged as between two millstones, without rights, without soil, without the slightest prospect of any independence, of an autonomy such as the other peoples hope sooner or later to win and will win; at every hour exposed as a target to the fury of the populace, swinging to and fro between Poles and Russians, thereby losing more and more of their own character and drifting towards a moral insanity, — such is the present gloomy state of affairs, from which every impartial person can piece together for himself the picture of the future of the Jews within Russia . . . But outwardly, too, the picture is gloomy enough.
In the course of the last 25 years, since the Jew-baitings of 1881, some 1½ millions have emigrated from Russia. In recent years the number of emigrants has almost equalled the natural increase. But wherever the Jews may go in larger bands, everywhere they carry the Jewish question, that is, antisemitism, with them in their knapsack; the greater the number of emigrants in any country, the more threatening the Jewish question becomes there. The gates of America are gradually beginning to close; England fears the Jewish paupers and passes the Aliens Bill. A veritable shudder comes over one in reading the reports of the hardships and torments to which the emigrants are subjected already at the Prussian frontier, and which grow still worse in Hamburg, Bremen and other port towns. The shameful examination to which they must submit is like the examination of the plague-stricken. It very often happens that the wretches make the journey twice, from Hamburg to New York and from New York back to Hamburg, only to be cast back in the end once more upon Russia. A part of the emigrants perishes from sickness and privation of every kind; but even those who gain a footing in England or America lead a miserable life. For since they come into highly civilised countries ignorant of the language, unacquainted with the manners and customs, and equipped with neither the mental nor the physical armour to take up the competitive struggle with their new host-people, they remain inferior there too, citizens of the second or third class. They form new American Ghettos, as the Chinese do, fall into the sweating system or become pedlars, arouse the displeasure of their new surroundings by the multitude of unsympathetic peculiarities, mostly of an outward nature, brought over from the Russian home, and in this way become a target of hatred and contempt. A part of them, indeed, is absorbed into the population; but the greater part, which receives an incessant influx from Roumania, Galicia and Russia, swells the number of the lumpenproletariat. The picture becomes all the sadder when one considers that the Jews mostly crowd together in the towns, without the slightest inclination to acquire land and in part to pursue agriculture, which would surely be the most natural and expedient way of carrying on a healthy colonisation and of bringing about the recovery of the physically decayed Ghetto race.
The desperate situation of a people numbering 5–6 millions, which will not die and cannot live, a situation not first created by the October days or the troubles in Russia, but which has of late merely assumed more acute forms, has indeed manured the soil for Zionism from time immemorial; the situation of the Jews in Roumania and Galicia has fertilised it, and antisemitism in other countries has brought it to ripeness. It is an error to believe that Herzl created it; the reverse is the case. Herzl, that great man with the heart of gold and the will of iron, merely gave it a concrete shape. Herzl put the question clearly and unambiguously: either the Jewish people still exists as such and is able once more to gather itself together and to make a whole out of its scattered members, or it can no longer do so. The test of the sum was the Basle Congresses, which he created. This tribune, upon which the Jewish question was to be taken in hand, became precisely the place where the right of the Jews to self-determination was decreed. It was resolved there that the Jews must once and for all take their fate into their own hands, instead of depending on the grace of their host-peoples. The first condition for this is a land, a territory, as I have already mentioned. The whither appeared to Herzl at first very clear and evident: "The land of our fathers — Palestine."
This synthesis — a thinly peopled land, fertile indeed but neglected, on an autonomous basis, and moreover the former homeland to which the Jewish masses are bound by countless traditions — seemed to him one of the happiest for bringing the Jewish question to a final solution, all the more so as already 25 years ago, after the anti-Jewish riots of 1881, the first beginnings of a colonisation of Palestine had been made. With superhuman effort and the straining of his eminent talent, to the point of self-sacrifice, he set every lever in motion to attain the goal he had set. He obtained audiences of almost all the crowned heads of Europe, from the Emperor William to the Pope; he exerted all his powers to make the Jewish question an international one and to win the authoritative circles for a settlement of Palestine on an autonomous basis. He achieved much — but the main thing he did not achieve: the Sultan, who heaped honours of every kind upon him, who lodged him as his guest and conferred orders upon him — declared to him at last that there could be no question of ceding Palestine to the Jews.
This failure, however, by no means discouraged Herzl. When he had perceived that the synthesis — a free people in its own land — was not attainable for the present, he evolved Zionism and confined himself ad hoc to wishing to obtain the half of this synthesis — a free territory. At bottom it is indeed decisive that the people should first revive before its own land is regained. Without a Jewish people — no Jewish land; and it might well happen that, before the constellations in Turkey so shaped themselves that Palestine could be obtained for the Jews, there would be no more Jews left to occupy it. — In Herzl's never-resting mind a new combination now arose. Between Palestine and Egypt lies a strip of land, the Sinai Peninsula together with El Arish, a territory on the Mediterranean Sea which belongs not to Turkey but to Egypt, that is, to England. Thither Herzl now turned his gaze. He fitted out an expedition of expert men — with the late Goldsmid at its head — which explored this territory thoroughly in every direction. The undertaking foundered, however, on the opposition of Lord Cromner, the English Resident, who would not give up the Nile water for irrigation, and moreover on the great cost of constructing waterworks. Then Chamberlain hit upon the idea of ceding to us a territory in East Africa, on a high plateau lying on the Equator, to one side of the railway from Mombassa which leads into the interior of the country, known under the name of "Uganda."
Now, in order not to try the patience of this highly honoured assembly too severely, and on the other hand animated by the wish not to provoke the slightest discord in an assembly which desires to help our people unitis viribus, I pass over in silence the Uganda affair, which lasted 2 years and bred much bad blood; I will only mention briefly that the 7th Congress declined England's magnanimous offer and declared by a majority of votes that it would accept no other territory whatever that might possibly be offered to it, except the one which is not offered to it.
But matters did not rest there; the minority of the Congress did not sit with folded hands, but sought to continue spinning the threads which Herzl had tied with England and to carry on the negotiations.
Zangwill took over the leadership of this group of political Zionists, which calls itself territorialist and has set itself the aim of obtaining from England a territory favourable for a Jewish settlement.
The territorialist movement is no fantastic, but an exceedingly real and practical one; the distress of the Jews has become a burning question, not only for the Eastern Jews themselves, but also for their Western co-religionists, to whom the headlong emigration of Russian Jews might become exceedingly burdensome, indeed unbearable. We must now make use of this moment of general feeling within the whole of Jewry to guide the emigration into right channels, into a healthy river-bed. We must seek an outlet. This, however, can only and solely come about if a territory should be created which would be suited to autonomous settlement, where the Jews could create values and win respect for themselves, that is, give proof of their capacity for healthy colonising. The unhappy people who now, without looking about them, go wherever the least resistance lies, could in time create for themselves a "Home," an "Ir-Miklot," towards which those too would look who remain in their present fatherlands. It is not a matter here of removing mountains, of carrying over 100,000 people at once into a