Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 1 · 5 January 1906
13printed page
scan 11 of 22

No. 1 — "Die Welt" — 13

(continued from page 12)

…ven services. The object of trade was — Jewish national autonomy; the commission claimed — the gracious promise of a few mandates both in the Galician Diet and in the Reichsrat; and the "honest broker," the saviour in the Poles' distress — Herr Dr. Byk, President of the Lemberg Jewish Community. Dr. Byk saw in the attainment of a Jewish national autonomy nothing more than the gaining of so and so many Jewish mandates. With a couple of mandates, he thought, the lamb that is always being shorn would be whole, the wolf sated, and Herr Dr. Byk — a saviour of the Poles and a benefactor of the Jews. Only one thing this resourceful head forgot: that there are still, thank God, Jews to whom the granting of a Jewish national autonomy by the Government is more than merely the question of a few mandates. Others again, perhaps less idealistically disposed, do not see why they, the Jews, should owe the mandates due to them first to Polish magnanimity, and so receive them only at second hand, when there is a possibility of getting them at first hand and of being beholden for them to no one, not even to Herr Dr. Byk .... Others still, Jews of yet more practical mind, have no confidence whatever in the promises of the Poles and the assurances of Dr. Byk. Of this, it seems, Herr Dr. Byk never thought at all. The first step that Herr Dr. Byk took in this matter was a — journalistic one. He published an article in the "Polish Correspondence," in which he combated a Jewish national autonomy by sophistries. — Proceeding from the assimilationist standpoint that we Jews are merely a religious community, we cannot, indeed may not, in his opinion, lay any claim to a Jewish national autonomy. We ought therefore, according to Dr. Byk, not to accept one even if the Government offers it to us. Besides, we are not at all ripe for autonomy. We also owe it, however, to the Poles among whom we live — which is presumably meant to say, are barely tolerated — to abandon such intentions. —

We are not a nation, if only because we have neither a language nor a land. Moreover, a Jewish national autonomy would be for him, Dr. Byk, by no means an advance but rather a step back into that bad old time of the Jewish ghetto. That, roughly, is the quintessence of that article.

But Herr Dr. Byk did not let matters rest there; he made the deed follow the written word. Hardly had the Reichsrat recess begun when he was already at work. A meeting of Jewish "notables" from Galicia was to pass a resolution in the sense desired by the Poles and present it to the Government. But in order to be quite sure of his cause, only a few people, about 22, among them 14 from the local communal board, all faithful sharers of Herr Dr. Byk's views, were invited. As a special precaution, the intended coup was even kept secret. It was really meant to be a conventicle, out of which, once the resolution had been passed, one could then make in the Polish press a solemn assembly of Jewish notables from every corner of Galicia. But once again the old proverb was to prove true: Nothing is spun so fine but it comes to the sun. In spite of all Herr Dr. Byk's caution, the Zionists got wind of it and sent a deputation to Dr. Byk with the request that they be permitted to take part in the deliberation of so eminently Jewish a question. It was brusquely turned away. Thereupon the local Zionist D. C. in all haste put itself in communication with the other Galician D. C.s, and all the towns of Galicia were called upon to protest by telegraph against the holding of such a conventicle and against its possible resolutions. A mass of such telegrams did indeed come in. Besides this, all the Zionist societies here met together and resolved to organise a demonstrative mass procession before the communal building during the sitting of the conventicle. On December 26, a. p., towards 4 o'clock in the afternoon, a procession of Jewish citizens, university men and workmen, numbering many hundreds, accordingly moved through the streets of the town towards the communal building. In front went the Poale Zion with flags and several large placards. An open-air popular meeting was intended before the communal building, in order to protest with a thousand voices against the resolutions of that miniature assembly; but the porter on duty now wanted to bar the gate, whereupon at that moment part of the demonstrators forced their way into the building and proceeded into the council chamber (the event, much exaggerated, taking place in such a way that several panes were pushed in). At the sight of the intruders Dr. Byk and his associates hastily left the hall and telephoned to the police. In the meantime the Zionists present in the hall occupied the seats that had become empty and held a protest meeting in the Kahal chamber. Once more a Zionist deputation went to Dr. Byk, but it was received only in consequence of urgent representations on the part of the police commissary, who had meanwhile arrived. Once again it was shown what an apt pupil Herr Dr. Byk is. He had quickly picked up from his Polish masters how one receives Jews, and aped it after them. Standing on the threshold, barring entry to the room with his body, he received the deputation. This time, too, the deputation was turned away in the most brusque manner, and Dr. Byk would not grant even its modest request to be allowed to attend the deliberation as spectators in the gallery, and he instructed the police commissary to have the hall cleared with all severity as soon as possible.

What impression Herr Dr. Byk's behaviour towards the Zionists made upon the outside participants in this conventicle, who are by no means in the odour of Zionism, appears clearly from the authentic remarks which they made in private conversation to a gentleman closely connected with the writer of these lines: "The manner in which the Zionist deputation was received by Herr Dr. Byk has aroused our fullest displeasure. One does not receive deputations on the threshold; and above all this deputation (the Zionist one) was, after all, the spokesman of a great party in Judaism. We were all in favour of calling in a few Zionists to the deliberation, and pointed out that the Zionist party, as a purely Jewish party, must not be excluded from taking part in the deliberation of so important a Jewish matter. But the gentlemen from Lemberg, and chiefly Herr Dr. Byk, would by no means admit it, and pleaded that in view of the demonstration it would look like intimidation." —

When the hall had been cleared by the police, the conventicle continued its deliberations. On the part of several participants the conduct of the Poles towards the Jews was also subjected to sharp criticism, and after a deliberation of several hours that resolution was passed whose wording has already been published in your esteemed paper of December 29, a. p. — But for one hour the luxuriously furnished communal chamber offered a picture of the future. The doors were flung wide open, and in stormed the Jewish youth with its Jewish heart and its purely Jewish ideals. For one hour pure, healthy air blew away that decades-old, bewildering mustiness. j. s. p.

S. H. Kolomea, January 2, 1906. The question of the recognition of Jewish nationality in the electoral reform in Austria has won many adherents with us, in one of the largest towns of Eastern Galicia, and has called forth energetic activity. On the initiative of the working convention of the Zionist societies ("Beth Israel," "Z'irê Zion," "Rachela," "Safa Chaja" and "Poale Zion") a committee has been formed, consisting of the most authoritative men of our town, which is working with all its strength to set on foot an action for the recognition of Jewish national autonomy. The chairman of this action committee is Herr Dr. Salomon Rosenheck. The first work of this committee was to send by telegraph to all the great Austrian daily papers an energetic protest against the meeting convened by Dr. Byk and his associates, in which it denied them the right to come forward in the name of the Jews. It was further resolved to distribute among the people an appeal printed in 10 000 copies, in which the significance of Jewish national autonomy is made clear and the Jews are called upon to stand up for autonomy with all their strength. In view of the resolutions of the Galician districts, a great popular meeting has been convened for Sunday, the 7th inst., with the single item on the agenda: "The Attitude of the Jews to the New Electoral Reform." For the 15th inst. a still larger popular meeting with the same agenda is planned, at which Dr. Straucher, Member of the Reichsrat, from Czernowitz, will appear as speaker. It was further resolved to send a commission from house to house, beginning as early as the 1st inst., to collect signatures. On December 30 of last year the town preacher here, Herr Isaak Weber, spoke in the great synagogue on Jewish national autonomy. His polished sermon made a deep impression on the great crowd. For the 7th inst. several university men will visit the neighbouring towns and convene popular meetings there.