Page 14 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition No. 2
That, unfortunately, is the situation in Palestine. Work in Palestine is opposed to diplomacy, and diplomacy is opposed to work in Palestine. (Cries: Quite right.)
Our poor Herzl too was faced with this dilemma: either he had to give up activity in Palestine or give up diplomacy; and out of his political instinct he resolved to give up activity in Palestine (applause and dissent) and to continue upon the path of high politics; for Herzl already had at that time the experience which Ussischkin, and, as I fear, the majority of Zionists in general, do not yet possess even now: that Zionism exists to create conditions and not things. If we think it our task to build up a people economically in an artificial manner, then we are on the road to ruin, for upon this rock the Ika too came to grief. If all the millions of the Rothschilds and of the Hirsch Foundation and of all the Jews were put together into one fund, we should nevertheless be bound to fail.
Mr. Ussischkin heaps up a great number of ideal qualities and says: if a people does not possess all these, "then all its attempts to form a political centre must remain without success." Since no people on the whole earth possesses all these qualities — as, for instance, that no individual should be permitted to make a profit by the sale of land to non-Jews, or that our young men from every country should serve three years as agricultural labourers in Palestine — therefore Mr. Ussischkin ought to withdraw from the movement and not squander the money and strength of his people. Fortunately such qualities are not necessary. Australia was founded with convicts. There has never been such a whole nation of idealists in the course of history, and we Jews are certainly not one. Our State need not rest upon idealists, but upon the struggle of ordinary men for their bread. Idealists can merely provide the conditions; they can supply banner and idea, they can give the land, the freedom, and the conditions for an autonomous government — but that is all that any power on earth can do. You have no institutions to create; you need not be ashamed that you cannot point at every Congress to a new colony or a new factory.
You are here to create not things, but conditions. Give the people the conditions. It will create the things. All that you have to do is to show that with every year we draw nearer to the conditions.
The same misunderstanding underlies the idea that, if we accepted the East African territory, we Zionists should not have the means to develop it. It will develop of itself. We have only to create conditions; not things. And the most important conditions we have already created. We have smoothed the way for our people to a free life upon free soil. The opinion that we must ally ourselves with other bodies is senseless. That would mean a second Ica. The people must found the State, not the State the people.
So I agree with Herzl in the view that an East African territory is acceptable as a means of getting to Palestine. I give you 6 brief reasons for my decision:
-
Because an autonomous colony in Palestine already signifies half of the Basle Programme. It is not Palestine itself, but it is a publicly and legally secured home. One may dispute whether it is the more important or the less important half; certainly it is the more difficult half of the way. To obtain a territory is not hard; but to obtain independence, to be able to live again as a nation after 18 centuries of homelessness, that is immensely hard. And if we miss this opportunity, I do not know when we shall have a new one.
-
The Basle Programme demands the strengthening of Jewish self-consciousness. Can you conceive of anything that would better serve this end than a Jewish flag waving over Jewish land? That will turn anti-Zionists and non-Zionists into half-Zionists, and half-Zionists will soon become whole Zionists.
-
Because it signifies, moreover, the rescue of tens of thousands, perhaps hundreds of thousands, of wandering Jews, and will preserve them as an organised Jewish body upon their own ground and soil. This Jewish emigration is a concrete fact; every year a hundred thousand leave the Russian Empire. Why should they be scattered and swallowed up by alien civilisations, which throw their whole spiritual being off its course?
They will be drawn to a healthier life, bodily and spiritually, than in the overcrowded cities of the Old and New World. Even Messrs. Kaiser and Wilbusch admit that the Jewish people is as capable as any other of forming a flourishing State of its own. Are we then less skilful than the people who in swamp and desert founded Venice, or Australia, or New England, or even Salt Lake City? That this creation may delay the acquisition of Palestine is possible; but the other methods are not quicker, and we should not have the consolation of independence.
- Because from a Jewish State we are better able to work for Zionism. We have to-day received some touching telegrams from Manchuria. In a Jewish State we shall be able to conduct our own affairs, interrupted only when we had to stand up for England, and not interrupted by any world quarrels whatever.
In our State we shall work undisturbed for Zionism, not only directly but also indirectly, because we shall train the peasant and pastoral element that will be needed by us in Palestine. In our State we shall also learn once more to govern ourselves.
-
Because, if you tell the Sultan that we will work only on Turkish soil, you shut out all competition, all rivalry, and screw up the political price of Palestine to an enormous height.
-
My last reason is the simplest and the shortest, namely this: that Uganda was offered to us and Palestine is refused us. (Great applause.) The Congress therefore has, properly speaking, no practical rival plan at present.
If you reject the East Africa project, you will rejoice just as if you had had a bad tooth drawn; too late you will remember that this was our only tooth!
The English Government is the only one in the world with which we have diplomatic relations. If these are cut off, we are poor indeed.
Ladies and gentlemen! You are all of literary training, and know the Sibylline Books, and know also what Shakespeare has said: