Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 29 · 21 July 1905
2printed page
scan 2 of 38

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 29

(continued from page 1)

…the idea of creating such a factor of power was bound to come to light among this weakest of all peoples in a tangible form capable of realisation, all the more so as this people lacks every other means of power. And so we see that this thought found its first, and indeed magnificent, expression already in the proceedings of the First Congress. The members of the Congress all had the feeling that, if a Jewish National Fund were to be created, it would have to be very considerable and command respect. Professor Schapira, the mathematician, who was accustomed to reckon with infinities, surely thought he was descending from the heights of the universe when, in his draft statutes, he wished to have this fund fixed at no less than 10 million pounds, and any encroachment upon its principal made conditional upon a plebiscitary vote of rejection or approval. One positively senses a painful turn when one sees him, in his introduction, slip down into a petty shopkeeper's way of looking at things and hears him ask for only about one million pounds, though this as an iron fund. If one wishes to be honest, one must admit that this sum, as the possession of an individual, may well signify wealth, but that, if one applies the measure of a state and a people and considers that, for example, a country at war, even with the other requisite means at its disposal, would scarcely make such a sum last a week, one must truly call it insignificantly small. Now, however, the experiences of the subscription collections for the Jewish Colonial Bank seem to have made us far more modest, so that at the Fifth Congress Gg. Kremenezky spoke only of a sum of £200,000. Whoever is able to rise above the viewpoint of private economy, and has for but a moment an ear and an understanding for the language of events in the field of state and national economy, must accompany this change in opinion regarding the size of the Jewish National Fund with bitter feelings. Arrived at this standard, the whole must truly be regarded as child's play. But worse is yet to come...

In the face of this dwarfish creation one might still have reconciled oneself to the thought that the initiators had in mind the motive that one must begin small, and that as soon as a considerable sum had come together, the petty-bourgeois outlook of those concerned would likewise widen into a statesmanlike one, and with the growth of the national possession the incentive to collect and enlarge would also increase. It is, after all, a well-known fact that the poor man spends small amounts far more lightly than the rich man, because the former, accustomed to the habits of poverty, again and again has nothing to which he might add the little sum, and so the fulfilment of a trifling wish is already worth more to him than the small value in his hands; whereas the latter denies himself something far more easily, because he is in a position to add the small sum to an already existing stock and so enlarge it, and with him the forgoing of many a small pleasure is therefore outweighed by the joy of increasing his possessions. Even had it been possible to prevent this homespun insight from the economic life of the private person from being applied to the striving of a people for power, one was bound, at the very next, the Sixth Congress, upon the adoption of the Tschlenow motion—whereby even the figure of, say, 200,000 Pounds Sterling was abandoned and it was resolved to proceed at once to the purchase of land—to be painfully instructed that in the Congress those elements prevailed among whom there can most decidedly be no question of a statesmanlike mind, nor even of the possibility of a statesmanlike conception.

While every individual knows only too well even in private life that acquisition on a small scale, the so-called purchase en detail, comes far dearer than making purchases wholesale and thereby sparing the middlemen and agents, together with their fees and necessary profits, not even this minimum of insight could prevail, in the administration of a nascent national estate, against the unreckoning moods of the moment. To be sure, the old mistrust of the Easterners towards the Westerners, the after-effects of the Minsk Congress, at which the non-political element had decidedly predominated, and the incidental affair of the East African project*) had so sad an effect that it was believed the meaningless sum collected could best be secured by not, indeed, applying it to the goal, but squandering it beside the goal. The circumstance, too, that members and societies of other peoples are acquiring individual properties in Palestine acted, in the sultry fear of losing the whole, upon the minds and hearts of the members of the Congress like a great fire—bewilderingly. In such calamities one very often observes that some woman who has lost her head, instead of snatching valuable goods, jewellery, better clothing and money from the flames, flees the scene of the fire with an oven-board, which she has rescued from the devouring fire.

By way of illustration, however, I should like to relate the following anecdote: Of a poor Jew in Brody, whose wife was constantly dinning into his ears the wish that he should acquire a cow for the household, it is told that in striking succession he brought home one day four cow's feet, the next day a cow's head, and then again a whole loin, and after that lungs and liver together, all of which the wife used again and again in the kitchen for the best meals and dainties. When she thereupon asked him why he spent so much money on such quantities of meat, he answered: "My child, it is your wish that we should have a cow. We cannot acquire one all at once, but little by little we shall get there." The poor man did not notice that, by the time the cow should be pieced together in this fashion, it could only be a dead cow, which moreover would already have been eaten up on the way to its assembly. Thus, in fact, will the consequences of the resolution provoked by Dr. Tschlenow at the Sixth Congress present themselves, and this I shall prove in what follows. But let me first be permitted a side-glance at another Zionist institution, which was likewise good in idea, but which in execution, and in particular through the entanglement that came about in practice with the use of the National Fund, was forced into a mistaken field.

*) VI. Protocol. 287. Dizengoff's remark.