Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 28
(continued from page 3)
…be created and strengthened, Jews of means from Russia and Roumania, from Galicia and other countries, buy land in Palestine, themselves cultivate their landed property as Ottoman subjects, and so increase the Jewish labour force there. Given the position the Jews hold in those countries of emigration, they would still gain, and by no means lose, as Turkish subjects, while they would render inestimable services to the national cause. They would be the true pioneers, since they would contribute to dispelling mistrust in Turkey and to awakening confidence and the conviction that the Jew constitutes a quiet, state-preserving and state-promoting factor. If they then created for themselves, under the religious title of Chacham Baschi, a capable head, supported also by the Jews of the Galuth, who could appear with the requisite splendour of a patriarch or exarch, they would also form a political factor and acquire important political rights and privileges.
Whoever knows the conditions in the East will agree with me.
I should further like to see — and it would be one of the finest tasks of the Chowewe Zion societies of the whole world — work done to the end that the Jewish community in Jerusalem, Safed and Tiberias be drawn away from the existence of Luftmenschen, from schnorrerism and from Chaluka-begging, to work on the soil, to the arts and crafts and other wholesome trades, and to cottage industry. The latter is a matter of honour for the Jewish people, so that the pilgrims from every corner of the inhabited earth may not again and again gain the impression that the Jew in his own land — and that it is his, nobody after all doubts — feels comfortable on the level of the lazzaroni and mendicant friars, while members of other nations labour at the revival of the desolate soil and earn merit thereby.²) In these two points my Chowewe-Zionism, which I hold to be honest and practicable, is exhausted, and political Zionism could promote it by the creation of general institutions, such as a model farm, meteorological stations, information bureaus, participation by the banks in industrial undertakings, etc. — The Territorialists, too, are in great part, and within certain limits,³) right. Let me be sharply criticised again in the "Haschiloach" and held up as an apostate. I persist in my standpoint that, if we already had Palestine, it would be not only good but necessary, for more than one reason, to have other secondary centres as well, which would see in the Jewish community to be created in Palestine their chief centre of culture, their heart, with which they would stand in constant contact, to which they would send material goods for its strengthening and their youth for training and elevation, and from which, besides many material things, they would draw above all their spiritual goods. And if I am smiled at with the superior air of the statesman, and it is pointed out that among other peoples a metropolis existed first and only then were colonies sought and founded abroad, and that it would mean beginning the work
²) Ussischkin, "The Four Watchmen", in the Year-Book of the "Achiasaf" 1904/5, pages 245—250.
³) The limitations consist in not drawing upon the means collected for Palestine. On this, a separate study.
at the wrong end if one were first to create the latter and then proceed to the formation of the centre, I reply that the life of the Jewish people in the Galuth could never develop normally, that we have already been compelled to begin many things at the wrong end, and that we would by no means have to — indeed, would not even be permitted to — cease continuing without interruption our efforts for and in Palestine, even if a part of the Jewish people were to occupy itself successfully with the solution of the other problem that seemed more agreeable to it. So many groups of Jews perform the work of assimilation; others again bring new fields of culture under the plough among foreign nations, for which they will never be thanked; all of them spheres of activity that represent for us Zionists a gnawing deficit. Why should we not tolerate and treat with sympathy such Jews of ideal aspiration as place themselves after all in the service of Jewish nationalism and direct their gaze to the whole body of their kinsmen, and especially to the impoverished masses? Would it not be more correct, instead of fearing competition and a diversion of forces, rather to see in them allies who pursue the same aims, though by other roads, but who, like the results they are to attain, will in the end serve the one great national cause?
To be sure, it is a great fault of the Territorialists when individual hotheads go so far as to combat our final goal, Palestine. But they were brought to this aberration only by defiance in consequence of the ostracism on the part of the zealots among their opponents, who, as in the Middle Ages, came marching up straightway with excommunication and Cherem.
Even the extremists among the Territorialists sense that in combating the Palestine idea they are sawing off the branch on which they sit. They cannot, after all, forget that Zion was the magic word which brought together the national Jews of all lands and zones, and that the historical element contained in it, with all its imponderables of feeling, was precisely what galvanised many dead members of Jewry and awakened them to new Jewish life. That is why their demand is directed towards giving the Jewish organisation a federative form, whereby they forget that every federal organisation in the life of nations has as its basis rootedness in the soil, autochthony, the absence of which constitutes for the present the most conspicuous deficiency of the Jewish people. That would be the application of a form from an utterly alien domain. If the Territorialists had in view a definite territory, and with the same legal powers as, say, East Africa before it became better known, and came with it to the Congress, they may rest assured that it would have to be subjected to an honest examination and, if found good, receive support. Zionism, as the regeneration movement of Jewry, could not and cannot dismiss such a proposal out of hand without at the same time abdicating its position in the eyes of the Jewish people and of the whole world. Should the ideological riders of principle wish to fight against it in the name of principle, then they would, in view of the treatment meted out to the Jews, of the system of starvation carried through against them with cruel consistency in Galicia, of their degradation to pariahs in Roumania, of the, by the government at least not prevented,