Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 20 · 19 May 1905
4printed page
scan 4 of 20

Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 20.

(continued from page 3)

…Sea as its boundary, and on the east the Jordan and the Dead Sea. This territory comprises over 12 000 square kilometres and had in the year 1900 a population of 320 000 souls. Accordingly its density of population is expressed by the figure 26, that is, exactly half of the figure cited by Zangwill. There is in fact no reason to suppose that since 1900, that is, in scarcely five years, the population of this Liwa has doubled. An increase has taken place only in the towns of Jerusalem and Jaffa. And herewith we touch upon the fundamental error of Mr. Zangwill's statements, both for the Liwa of Jerusalem and for the United States. In the first case, given the small area of the Liwa, Mr. Zangwill has reckoned in the population of the large towns (even then his figure is twice as great as the real one), and so obtains a relatively high population figure per square kilometre. If we deduct from that of the whole Liwa the population of the three towns of Jaffa, Gaza and Jerusalem, at about 135 000 souls, we obtain as the population of the open country (including the smaller towns) 185 000 souls, that is about 15¹/₂ per square kilometre. This also corresponds to the actual conditions. Anyone who knows Palestine could not but be astonished at Mr. Zangwill's statement.

On the other hand, Mr. Zangwill operates with the population figure of the United States, outwardly, it is true, on the same principle, but in its sense in the opposite direction. He throws together the population figure of the well-populated East of the United States with that of the thinly populated West, and in this way obtains a population of only 26 persons per square kilometre. Whereas in Palestine we have a more or less uniformly thinly settled country, possessing only a few more densely populated towns, the United States consist of two great regions whose conditions of population are entirely different, and which yield an average that can have no force as proof.

We can therefore console Mr. Zangwill. We shall not be compelled, after the example of our fathers, to drive the tribes that possess Palestine out of the land, sword in hand. There is land enough in Palestine. It must, to be sure, be acquired and cultivated in order to permit a greater density of population. With the modern aids of agriculture and of hydraulic engineering we shall be able, on the fertile soil of Palestine with its mild, subtropical climate, to feed five times the population. If one assumes that Palestine is only 29 000 square kilometres in size (though I hold it, with the land east of the Jordan and the Hauran, to be at least 35 000 square kilometres in size), then with its 650 000 souls of population it now has only 18 souls per square kilometre. Over three million people can confidently lead a materially carefree existence upon this area.

Moreover, Mr. Zangwill is in contradiction with his own statements. He says that in the Liwa of Jerusalem we do not make up even 25% of the population. If we reckon the Jewish population of Jerusalem at as much as 50 000, that of Jaffa at 10 000, that of Hebron at 2000, and that of the other places and of the Jewish colonies in this Liwa at 3000 souls, we obtain here a total Jewish population of about 65 000 souls, which, with a total population of 320 000 souls, does in fact make up about 20%, that is, "not even 25%." But should the Liwa, according to Zangwill's statements, have a population of 52 souls per square kilometre, it would have to be inhabited by 640 000 people (that is, by the population of the whole country), and the Jews would make up 10% of the population. Now there are in fact some 20 000 further Jews (Safed with about 11 000, Tiberias with about 4000, the colonies and the rest of the country with some 5000 more) in Palestine besides the approximately 65 000 living in Judaea, and these form about 12¹/₂% of the total population of the country. And so Mr. Zangwill also states it, when he says: "Now we make up merely 12% of the population." How then does he arrive at his statements of 52 souls per square kilometre in the Liwa of Jerusalem and of 25% Jewish population in this Liwa, which would amount to some 160 000 Jews for the Liwa alone?

Yet another assertion of Mr. Zangwill's does not quite correspond to reality. He says, namely, "that a great part of the holy soil is in the hands of private owners and could not become ours at once, even if we already had the Charter; whereas the Crown lands, which belong to the Sultan and could therefore be bought outright, are unfortunately plains not free from the exhalations of the soil and from fevers. And even these are already in part occupied by Mohammedans from Barbary and the Balkans." That a great part of the Palestinian soil, indeed by far the greatest part, whether it be pure private property (Mulk) or State land left to the hereditary usufruct of private persons (Mirie), has its owners, is entirely correct. And here in fact no Charter will help us over the difficulty. The soil of Palestine must come to us by the private-economic way of purchase. With this fact we must once and for all reckon. But it is incorrect that the Crown lands, as it were in contrast to the other categories of property, can be bought outright. The Sultan does not sell his possessions, but leases them to peasants, who as tenants of the Crown domain feel themselves better off than anywhere else in Turkey. For the dues are more bearable in this case (the tenants of the Crown domains pay no tithe, but only 20–25% of the gross yield as rent), and the treatment on the part of the officials of the Liste civile is uniformly good. The leasing of Crown domains comes very much into consideration for our aims, and we must take thought to obtain concessions to this effect from the administration of the Liste civile. Nor is it correct that these lands are for the most part occupied. Mohammedans from the Balkans are found in Palestine in one single place only, namely the Bosnian settlement at Caesarea, founded since 1884, on land that does not belong to the Sultan. Maghrebis are found in one place belonging to the Sultan, namely in the village of Samach on the eastern bank of the Jordan, immediately after its exit from the Lake of Tiberias. To the Sultan belongs the greatest part of the fertile and well-watered Jordan plain, whose northern part is indeed marshy and is inhabited by harmless Bedouins (Ghawarine). This region, however, could be excellently cultivated after the draining of the marshes, and could feed a large population (Cf. Furrer in No. 2 of "Altneuland," 1905).

We see, then, that matters do not look so terrible with regard to the immigration of Mohammedans from Barbary and the Balkans. Far more important for us is the immigration of Circassians, to which Mr. Zangwill ought to have pointed, who have founded a flourishing village, Kafr-Kama, near Sedschera, and beyond the Jordan a number of villages around Kunetra in the north and near Dscherasch in the south. (The dying Circassian village near Hedera is of no consequence.) This immigration is especially furthered by the Mutessarif of Kerak. The Circassians are, it is true, no match for us economically; but all the same, in the present state of culture of the country, they are a competitor not to be despised.

Then Mr. Zangwill says: "We shall have to contend with the problem of a foreign population, which consists for the most part of Mohammedans and has for centuries been accustomed to despise us." We have seen that the problem of the foreign population in its act-