Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 13 · 31 March 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 13 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7


The Jews in the German Army.

In the German Reichstag a little chapter of the Jewish question was once again drawn into the debate a few days ago. Deputy Eickhoff of the Liberal People's Party pointed out, as he had done the year before, that the principle of equal rights is by no means granted to the Jews in the army. The Jews occupy an inferior position in the army, and particular care is taken to bar the Jews from the officer's career. This slighting of the Jews within the army manifestly constitutes a violation of the Constitution.

Deputy Ledebour concurs in the findings of Deputy Eickhoff and confirms that a prejudice against the Jews prevails in the army, which finds expression above all in the fact that Jews are not promoted to be officers.

The answer which the Minister of War, von Einem, found to this charge was very lukewarm. The Minister of War declared "that the Jewish religion can under no circumstances furnish a reason for not promoting anyone." That is to say, that the Constitution contains no provision whatever under which the Jews are to play a part of inferior rank in the army. A statement which can hardly be regarded as a vigorous refutation, for no one had put forward the assertion that the wording of the law bore an anti-Jewish tenor. The whitewashing of the fundamental laws of the State was therefore somewhat out of place, and it could succeed all the more easily since no one had doubted that equal rights are constitutionally guaranteed to the Jews.

The remaining parts of the Minister of War's speech, on the other hand, looked rather like a confirmation of the charges raised by Deputy Eickhoff than like a refutation. Instead of protesting against the assertion that the Jews are by no means gladly seen in the army, the Minister of War stated with great frankness the reasons why the Jews are regarded with jaundiced eyes. He said: "But in fact there exists, reaching into the widest circles of the people, an antagonism to Judaism. The Christian comrade does not like to serve together with a Jew. But this must be borne, not by me, but by those who do not want him; it must be borne also by Deputy Böckler." If one chose, one could, following the order of the words, take the last sentence ambiguously and believe that the word "this" in the sentence "But this must be borne etc." refers to the "Jew" immediately preceding; whence the sense would then follow that one is admonished, with indulgent mildness, to "bear" the Jew. (somewhat as one must, sighing, "bear" a burden that is not at all agreeable.)

A further section of the Minister of War's speech was — an indictment of the "papers" that stand under Jewish direction and are subsidised with Jewish money. When the Minister of War rose from his seat, many perhaps supposed that he meant to break a lance for the Jews; but lo and behold, the lance on occasion drove against the Jews. — The Minister of War argued: the Jewish papers always say that the officers' corps is no longer at its proper level; how then can the claim be raised that the Jews should enjoy equal rights in the army? — — —

The causal nexus between these two propositions is not altogether clear. One might answer the Minister of War with the popular counter-question: "What has the one to do with the other?" Because individual "Jewish papers" have an anti-militarist bent, the inferior position of all Jews in the army is supposed to be justified? Hard to comprehend!

The Minister of War could not, in the end, avoid admitting: "Against the Jewish soldiers there is nothing to be said; they do their duty everywhere in peace, and would do it in war too." — Many thanks!

N. N.

*
* *

Once again a Jewish debate in the Reichstag. A Jewish debate whose course and character did not depart from the familiar one of all other Jewish debates. To be sure, in the Vienna Parliament, which sets the tone in parliamentary manners generally, the chief arrangers of Jewish debates in particular are exceedingly distinguished, delicate fellows, who also bring the discussion to the corresponding level. This ideal of a Jewish debate the proceedings in the German Reichstag have not yet attained. A little polemic springs up; there is a dispute over the military fitness of the Jews, in which all manner of nonsense and untruth is for the anti-Semites a weapon by no means to be despised. Against this, anti-Semitism is struck dead by quotations from the most authoritative quarters. Yet the conclusion does not remain without instruction after all. The Minister, in his sincerity and frankness, declares without circumlocution that the Prussian laws, and he, their guardian, are quite powerless in the face of tradition and of the actual will of the Prussian people, even though it expressed itself in quite unjustified prejudices.

This frank confession has at least the value that it may perhaps bring about in some a right understanding of things. If one observes the development of the German Jews in the last few years, one will certainly be able to note a progress in their self-determination. The original standpoint which official German Jewry adopted was that of the purest defence. According to it, the Jews had always to be armed for the defensive, to have at all times sufficient arguments to be able to justify their existence. The whole outlook of these Jews proceeds from this conception: there are good, noble men who have nothing to reproach the Jews with, most noble ones who even have the courage to defend them, and bad ones who attack them. The keynote of this conception still prevails at the present day, and three-quarters of the Jewish press are guided exclusively by it. If God, for instance, were to ordain that for four weeks all the anti-Semites in the world should fall silent, the majority of the Jewish newspapers would in that time have to die a miserable death of starvation.

In the last few years, however, a new, prouder and more self-reliant conception has broken through: no longer merely to step out of the way and defend oneself, but to come forward more boldly and demand one's rights, an idea to which in the first place the "Verband der deutschen Juden" owes its origin. We must undoubtedly regard this as a commendable advance along the line of development towards Zionism, although one might be inclined to believe that a struggle for rights outside Palestine runs counter to our tendencies. But it is precisely human dignity rousing itself that is the first condition for Zionism, and the demand for full human rights leads in its consequence to the Jewish homeland.

Those who do not arrive at this consequence, but stand still in the middle of the road, will at any rate have received from the answer of the German Minister of War a jolt towards forward movement. Has he not shown them, too, a wall which they are no longer able to break through? What avail interpellations in the Reichstag, what avails the assent of