Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 12 · 24 March 1905
9printed page
scan 9 of 20

No. 12 — "Die Welt" — Page 9

(continued from page 8)

…torialists, inferior to the Zion-Zionists in numbers and in means, are doing their utmost to counteract their intrigues. For the rest, however, the Yes-sayers slumber, still contented with their first victory, and neglect to do their duty in good time. Is there not, then, a pressing danger that the Congress will at last sink into the executive organ of the Odessa Committee?

If the all too feeble activity of the Yes-sayers in the defence and execution of the Uganda project was unpardonable while the great Leader was still alive, then their passivity at this time, when that mighty voice is silenced for ever, is a grave sin against our people. Can they deny that, if they persist in their inaction hitherto, the Uganda project will be buried? Or have they perhaps reason now to be of another opinion than at the last Congress? Has the Jewish situation perhaps become better since that time? Alas, the facts tell us the contrary: the ever-growing number of emigrants, of whom no small part find closed doors, the emigration laws of America and England, and so forth!

What, then, are our unhappy Jews, wandering aimlessly about, to do? How much longer can our people wait? Let those who will not be persuaded that the founding of a few colonies in despotic Turkey is the answer to this burning question now rouse themselves to work! Let meetings be held everywhere, and let the people be warned against the errors of the Zion-Zionists, and the reality of our aspirations be made plain to them. In spite of the resolution of the Vienna Conference we have not the possibility of using shekel moneys for our agitation; greater material sacrifices will therefore be required of us.

The Yes-sayers must organise themselves in societies and groups, uniting in one centre, whose chief demand must be the execution of the Uganda project at the Seventh Congress. At the same time, however, it must also be made clear to the people that, at the moment when Uganda must for any reason be abandoned, another territory will take its place.

Much is to be done, and our work will be no easy one, in view also of the not always irreproachable weapons which our opponents wield. But though our task be a difficult one, we have nevertheless this advantage over our opponents, that we preach no mysticism, but strive after something that can be realised. By energetic, self-sacrificing deeds, and not by a mystical yearning after Palestine, which we have not, and the attainment of which, as matters stand, appears excluded for the foreseeable future, will our people be helped. But the moment for applying energy will not always present itself! Let us not allow this first opportunity offered in the course of our sad history of wandering to pass by unused. Our task is hard, but it can be carried through.

Harder still is the yoke of bondage to bear for him whom it oppresses — or does it not oppress you?

Zionist-Territorialist Association of Berne.


The National Assembly of the Orthodox Jews in Hungary.

The great Sanhedrin which was lately convened in Hungary's metropolis for the fresh fortification of the Orthodox stronghold has a claim to occupy our attention in a higher degree. The purpose, the means and the appearance of this assembly, representing more than half a million Jews, are in themselves peculiar enough to be recorded by us also as a notable event of current Jewish history. But our interest is heightened still further by a more intimate circumstance. The champions in the fray that has here been opened against the non-Orthodox are no longer unknown to us. It is not long since their names rang in our ears like a battle-cry. It was in the weeks preceding the Misrachi Day, when their Orthodox conscience commanded them to send, to the Misrachim who appealed to their hospitality, curses instead of the hoped-for brotherly greeting. It is therefore comprehensible if we, whose holiest ideal they represented as a misdeed and an aberration, now gazed expectantly towards the tribune where Anti-Zion, in salutary contrast to our false doctrine, would reveal its conviction, its direction and its strength, and if we listened for what our adversaries, whom we had hitherto heard speak only from Mount Ebal, would now let us hear upon Gerizim. But in the treetops of Transleithanian Orthodoxy there blows a spirit that ever denies. This time, too, the Gedolim have brandished the torch not for illumination but for incendiarism. From the brief, meagre pronouncements which here and there rose like little oases out of the chaos of the Congress, no positive ideal, no purposeful endeavour could be constructed. As though Orthodoxy alone were exalted above all care for its possessions, as though its principles dwelt as easily in space as in thought, the leaders feel themselves relieved of the necessity of giving, through any one of the three hundred professional speakers present, to the public summoned as witness, a picture of the nature and significance of a separate position for Hungarian Orthodoxy, of sketching the field of its past and future activity, and of justifying it from any point of view whatever. For the Tanna is excused the commentary. And therefore the momentous chief object of the Congress — the striving for legal recognition of a separate Orthodox-Jewish confession — needed only to be set forth in the categorical imperative, without answer to the anxious question whether this rolling-on along the path of schism, brought about merely by dull inertia, is truly pleasing to God. Care was also taken that such naive voices of conscience could form no stronger chorus. More diplomatically than Hungary's greatest statesman, the provisional directorate had caused the Congress to arise from an electoral system which offered security enough that the holy assembly of the great men — as they modestly styled themselves — would be desecrated only in slight measure by those degenerates to whom the will of the Gedolim is no longer the supreme law. Every congregation — without regard to the number of its souls — might send, besides the rabbi, one delegate more — but only from its own midst! The representative of urban congregations of 5000 souls thus found himself confronted by fifty opponents who together represented the same number. Like every virtue, the Orthodox one dwells in the flat country, and since the "reliable" counties of the north-east are thickly sown with small village congregations, there was reassurance in advance that the elements breathing the sinful atmosphere of urban culture would vanish in the ritual sixtyfold majority.

And yet the questionable means to a questionable end has proved a grave error of reckoning in the cunning calculation. For the plenary assembly, convened for the first time since the existence of the Orthodox party, ought, as an imposing manifestation of Orthodox Jewry, to have lent stronger emphasis to the demand for legal recognition of a separate Orthodox confession. But though it has succeeded, with the aid of an electoral trick,