Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 7 · 17 February 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 7 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

… is objected that Jews who emigrate to such a settlement would become East Africans, instead of remaining Jews. The possibility of remaining Jews must surely be greater in a Jewish settlement under Jewish autonomy than under the conditions now prevailing in Russia, or amid the temptations to sacrifice their Judaism to which the Jews in Western countries are exposed. It will at least be possible for them to lead a worthier life, they will at any rate be exposed to no persecutions, and all these circumstances must be favourable to a movement which strives for the restoration of a Jewish nation.

All these assertions I make without taking into consideration whether the report of the Commission will be favourable or unfavourable. In my opinion it is of the greatest importance for Zionism that some relief — material relief — should be afforded without delay to the Jews in their present position, for every day the difficulties of this position and the dangers to our national future increase. If, then, East Africa does not prove suitable, another place must be sought for our purposes. Even if the Jewish State in Palestine belonged to a nearer future than we have a right to assume, I am nevertheless convinced that it would not be wise not to seek first to raise the condition of the Jews, if this can be done by a magnificent scheme of colonisation on a Jewish national basis. Our State can only be strengthened if, before its establishment, we can alleviate the lamentable material misery of the Jews! —

From this it follows, then, that East Africa is in no sense a rival of Palestine, and that it will assuredly not take its place. That can never be — nothing can replace Palestine for the Jew. There, and only there, can he again found a Jewish State; in Palestine, and only in Palestine, can we again become a nation. The conditions, however, under which we now live compel us to work for another purpose than that for which Palestine alone is reserved. This purpose has, of course, an existence of its own, but it serves our goal as the foundation-stone of the edifice. In what sense can it be said of us that we have given up one jot of our resolve to win for the Jewish nation a legally recognised home in Palestine, if we endeavour to relieve the position of the Jewish people on a national basis? We should, however, be unworthy indeed if we held rigidly to the fixed manner of realising a programme. We have said wherein alone, in our opinion, the final solution of the Jewish question lies, and I believe and hope that we should hold fast to it if we had fifty East Africas. From this principle we do not depart by a hair's breadth when we say that circumstances now demand an immediate relief of the position of the Jews, and we believe that this relief will be found in the great Jewish settlement which is now offered to us.

The circumstances which, in my opinion, precisely in the interest of the future Jewish State demand immediate remedy or relief, have no close or special connection with the fact that we are at best still far removed from possessing Palestine as a legally recognised home. For even if Palestine, as it now exists, were offered to us at the same time, I am not certain whether some place like East Africa — supposing that the conditions are favourable — would not be of infinitely great use to us.

The difficulties connected with finding room for so large a population as we wish to unite as a Jewish people under a Jewish State, or as would wish to be so united, would be considerably diminished if we had, besides Palestine, another large and almost uninhabited settlement. But all these considerations acquire still greater weight from the fact that to-day we do not yet possess an inch of Palestine, that is to say, that the Jew as such does not possess in the whole wide world one square inch of land that can be called Jewish. Why, then, should the Jews, who need it so sorely, reject an opportunity of obtaining something which can at any rate be marked as a visible spot of earth on a tolerably large map of the world? I have heard the objection that no land other than Palestine can have any attraction for the Jews, since this is the Holy Land. Nowadays, however, Palestine is no holy land. It never was such for us before it became the land of the Jews, and it never will be until it becomes our land anew, the centre from which the best Jewish ideals, the best Jewish culture will shine forth to all quarters of the world. I do not believe that these are so rigid, so little elastic, so incapable of progressive development, that a return to the conditions which prevailed two thousand years ago would be unavoidable when we find ourselves once more within the sphere of their influence. If — which I do not believe — Jewish ideals and Jewish culture were to stand in contradiction to the present needs of our people, if — which I believe just as little — they could be reconciled only with a superstitious veneration for Palestine as the grave of our past, then these ideals and this culture would stand self-condemned, hostile to progress and useless. But I think otherwise. I believe that our best ideals, our best culture, serve the real life of the present and of the future, and that those must assuredly place themselves under their influence who expect from Palestine the fulfilment of the wishes of the present day and not merely the perpetuation of the memory of a bygone age; that those value the past most who place it in the service of the future, and who use the land to save the people, and not the people to save the land. Were I not convinced that Palestine offers us the best security that the Jews can be preserved as Jews for the world, through the historic connection of our people with Palestine, and because it is the only spot of earth towards which, in the course of the centuries, our people in its bitter suffering has hopefully yearned back, its past alone would not for me justify the position which it occupies in our endeavours and our national life. And because I see in the East African scheme a possibility for the redemption of a great part of our people from conditions in which they must perish as Jews, and a possibility of bringing them under conditions which would preserve them as Jews, therefore I attach so great a value to this scheme.

It is often asserted that there is no ground whatever for anxiety about the future of our people, that it would be better to do nothing until we can form our people anew in Palestine. It is pointed out that two thousand years have passed, that we have been exposed to persecutions and have met with toleration, that on the one hand we have been walled up in filthy ghettos, like human refuse, and on the other the high-