No. 36. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13.
(continued from page 12)
…epoch by at the very least half a century, and for that reason became to his opponents the most hated of agitators and prophets of evil, and even to his brothers-in-arms an inconvenient man and the man of suspicious escapades. And withal there was nothing in his whole nature that could have served to bring the real antagonisms to a mild settlement. He always acted fortiter in re and almost never suaviter in modo. His boundless pride of personality, fully justified though it was in my conviction, could not but appear to his contemporaries as insufferable arrogance; and his manner, rooted in the depths of his being, of grinding his expression to the sharpest conceivable precision made him a terrible polemicist who, like his kindred spirits Börne and Heine, was wont to flay his opponents in a positively Apollonian fashion. His fiery temperament, his pride that respected no bounds, his noble courage to place himself fearlessly in every breach, were appreciated only by the best of his time in every camp: the Philistine, however, found him frightfully trying to the nerves.
To this day the Jewish revolutionary is the abhorrence of Christian-Conservative circles; far more still has the bourgeoisie preserved a deserved hatred for him than for the man who successfully laid the axe to the root of its power; and even among the working class, since his death, strong forces have been at work, if not to disfigure his nature before posterity, then at least to conceal it. Here the old envy of Karl Marx and his followers still works powerfully on, the never wholly fought-out antagonism between national and international Socialism, between intransigent, often quietistic Radicalism and an opportunistic, warm-blooded statesmanship that dares to grasp at power because it trusts itself with the strength to wield it as well.
In the critical turning of the ages in which we are now living, it has become almost harder still for Everyman in every political camp to appreciate Ferdinand Lassalle without prejudice. For now we are witnessing that he is proved right in all essentials even as against his greatest opponents, Bismarck and Marx, let alone as against the "bourgeoisie"! Defeated while living, because he had — a fault, by the way, which he shared, for example, with Marx and his followers — quite monstrously overestimated the tempo of development, he now carries off, in death, a complete triumph. In a conversation, as Oncken reports, Bismarck once remarked to Lassalle that he would wait and see who "could eat cherries with the Devil the longer." Now it is becoming ever clearer that "in the upper storey," as Vischer might put it, Lassalle was right when he foretold from the introduction of universal and equal suffrage not, like Bismarck — who, to be sure, was proved right for the time being — a strengthening of the Prussian Crown against the Liberal bourgeoisie, but, beyond that, the rise of an overpowering democratic-socialist people's party. And in like manner he will be proved right against Karl Marx with his national Socialism and his opportunistic tactics; hardly any unprejudiced observer will care to doubt it even to-day. The Millerands and Bernsteins, the Schippels and Davids are at bottom Lassalleans, and to them, in spite of Dresden and Bebel, belongs the future of politics. Nay, I venture to declare still more: even as an economist Lassalle will be proved right against Marx! It cannot occur to me in the least to deny that Marx was the incomparably more learned and more profound economist, while Lassalle was never more than a dilettante who summarised the ideas of others; but for all that his intellectual personality was of such enormous, gigantic growth that he towered far above all his contemporaries, and with the intuition of genius knew how to stake out the guiding lines of development, even in this field foreign to him, more surely than the best specialists. His proposal to go to the root of social distress by means of the productive co-operative society will, in my conviction, bring about a turning of the ages within the shortest time — though, to be sure, in quite another field and with an essentially different organisation from what he believed.
But let one think of that as one will; in any case it requires to-day a scientific objectivity of the greatest rarity to grasp in its full greatness and its peculiar stamp this personality, which our time is only just now beginning to overtake. But to create so splendid a work as Hermann Oncken has given us in his "Lassalle"**) required more than scientific objectivity alone; to it there had to be joined, in equal measure, the most intimate knowledge of recent European, in specie of Prusso-German history, in its political as well as its cultural-historical and sociological unfolding; further, a deep understanding of economic problems and theories; and not least the full artistry of the sculptor who is able to restore to life, in plastic form, a great figure made familiar to him by psychological intuition. I do not hesitate to acknowledge Oncken's "Lassalle" as one of the best, soundest and most beautiful achievements of contemporary literature. If the work meets the fate it deserves, it will soon be found upon the tables of all cultivated German citizens.
Oncken at once grasps the deepest root of his hero when he conceives him as a Jew of German nationality. It is often said that the revolutionary vein lies in the blood of the Jews, and Oncken, too, seems inclined to this view. That, of course, is to be rejected, like all "race-theoretical" explanation of history whatsoever; one might with better right, conversely, represent the Jew as the type of Conservatism. But nothing is more certain and nothing more natural than that the Jew of to-day, in the Central and Eastern Europe of to-day, must be the born revolutionary; his milieu destines him to it with imperious force. Either he is a proletarian, and then naturally has the same tendency as the Christian proletarian against the feudal-capitalist order of the world which deprives him of his rights and exploits him — or by his circumstances he is a "bourgeois," and then his peculiar class position drives him with almost equal force against an order of things which to him alone denies a place in society, equality of rights, a part of the commercium and almost the whole of the connubium. This circumstance decides his political direction, the res of his life; and the same milieu then determines his conduct of life also, his modus, with almost as inescapable a force. Because the Jews must everywhere in social life first conquer the position which is conceded to every non-Jew as a matter of course; because the first presumption is everywhere just as much against them as it is in favour of every non-Jew — until the contrary is proved they are generally held to be non-gentlemen, the non-Jews to be gentlemen — therefore they stand perpetually on guard, in the fencer's posture. Everywhere attacked, or at least doubted, they must always first secure their personality, and from this there necessarily results that aggressive arrogance, which at the least asserts itself with emphasis, that is commonly said of the Jews not without justice, but is made a reproach to them without justice: one cannot possibly appear modestly in a circle in which one is not regarded as an equal among equals, yet in which one may claim equality of rights. And from this there results, further, that alleged racial quality of dazzling, advocate-like dialectic. He who stands hourly in combat has naturally the prospect, with equal endowments, of becoming a better fencer than he who rests secure in peaceful possession.
**) "Politicians and Political Economists." A collection of biographical portrayals of systems and characters. Edited by G. Schmoller and O. Hintze. 2. "Lassalle." By Hermann Oncken. 450 pages. Stuttgart 1904, Fr. Frommann (E. Hauff).