Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · 29 January 1904
8printed page
scan 8 of 24

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 5.

(continued from page 7)

…not be expelled. In the first place, they have at least the right to the protection of their domicile, even if the law disregards them personally. And in the second place, expulsion is not the right of a single State. To expel a foreigner means to send him back to his own country; but if he has no such country, we must keep him as an element forced upon us by the law."

Mr. C. deceives himself if he believes that the Roumanian Government did not know this. It knew it very well, for it had the expelled Jews smuggled into the neighbouring countries by the frontier gendarmes.

"Given the position of the Jews, it would really be logical that only the Roumanians proper should perform military service. By a beneficent anomaly, however, the law exempts from military duty only those foreigners who are subjects of another State. From the standpoint of military service, however, there is no longer any jus sanguinis. The provision that foreigners without a country shall perform military service is a good one, for it ties a bond between them and the country and strengthens their position. The Jews, who are the foreigners without a country, do not form, as some politicians among us assert, a race incapable of assimilation. This is nonsense, because no people in the world can dwell for any length of time among another without assimilating itself to it. Whoever asserts the contrary is guided by the antagonism which prevails, out of prejudice, between Jews and Christians. The hatred under which they have to suffer, the persecutions to which they are exposed, have only made the Jews more resistant, but not incapable of assimilation. The solidarity which one observes among them is the result of the persecutions to which they are exposed, and would, under the same circumstances, develop in any other group of men. We must work to the end that the antagonism between Jews and Christians may disappear. Our interest is not to breed hatred, but on the contrary to make our relations with the native Jews more intimate. The origin of this hatred must not be sought among us, for the Roumanian is good-natured, in proof of which I need only point to the good relations between Jews and Roumanians in the towns, and especially in the country. The origin of this hatred will have to be sought elsewhere. We must endeavour to develop our national activity in all its branches, without, however, disregarding the Jews, but rather by nationalising, likewise, the native Jews among them, with whom we have lived in peace for a long time."

For these opinions of his Mr. C. has already received his portion of blows. From the antisemitic papers — well, these do not count in a scholarly discussion — but also from another quarter, from a scholar of the same university, he has received an answer which differs in nothing from the abuse of the rough fellows in the antisemitic editorial offices. The Professor of Social Economy, Mr. A. C. Cuza, shortly after Mr. Cantacuzino's lecture, gave a counter-lecture, in which he strove to refute every sentence of Mr. Cantacuzino. Mr. A. C. Cuza is a well-known antisemite, and his arguments offer nothing new. But certainly no one will be able to deny originality to the following remark of Mr. University Professor Cuza:

"Mr. Cantacuzino says that the fact that the Jews in Roumania perform military service is an anomaly, and so do I assert — but then I cannot understand how he can say that it is beneficent. On the one hand 'anomaly' — and on the other 'beneficent'?" (Adeverul, report from Jassy.)

This way of putting the question is striking, and I am — I confess it — eager for Mr. Cantacuzino's answer. It proves sufficiently, after all, how matters stand with the logic of the non-antisemites in Roumania. A "beneficent anomaly"! risum teneatis amici, that is the most colossal Contradictio in adjecto of all the centuries, and it is Mr. A. C. Cuza of Jassy who has discovered it!

The conclusion which Mr. A. C. Cuza draws from the philosemitism (?) of Mr. Cantacuzino is no less interesting. Mr. Cuza proved, with his well-known compelling logic, that a man who can speak of the Jews as Mr. Cantacuzino has done cannot possibly be a Roumanian, but must be an outcast of the most corrupt quarter of Constantinople, the Phanar.

The newspapers added to their reports of this lecture of Mr. Cantacuzino that the lecture had reached the public and had caused an understandable stir, and had awakened great hopes among the Jews.

That is certainly incorrect. Neither the one nor the other is true. If one leaves aside the antisemitic papers, which are, after all, concerned for their daily portion of baiting and therefore bait the Jews with or without occasion, and Mr. C. A. Cuza — more correctly M. C. A. Cuza — who rails at the Jews for the length of a lecture every week, the stir which this speech has caused in Roumania is a slight one.

"Mr. Cantacuzino is generally regarded as a future Minister," foreign Liberal papers declare with promise. That is childish. Or does one perhaps wish to spoil Mr. C.'s ministerial career? Did not a real Minister, a Prime Minister, Mr. P. P. Carp, say — and not in an academic address, but in the Roumanian Chamber of Deputies — that Article 7 of the Roumanian Constitution is a barbarity, and what did that change in the position of the Jews in Roumania? It is certainly gratifying that in the Roumanian universities there are not only scholars of the stamp of Mr. Cuza, who at an examination (Social Economy) put to a candidate the question:

"What do you think should be done with the Jews?" and gave the highest mark to the candidate in question, who returned the smart answer: "Throw them out!" (Egalitatea, 2. I. 1904.)

It is gratifying — for the Roumanian. Th. Plebe.


From Russia.

St. Petersburg. The latest number of the official "Senatskija Wjedomosti" contains the following decision of the Senate on the Jewish question: "Children of Jewesses of Russian nationality who have contracted a marriage with foreigners, and who have thereafter, upon the death of their husbands or their divorce from them, returned to Russian nationality, possess the right, upon attaining their majority, to enter into Russian nationality. Concerning the right of the children of foreign Jewesses of non-Russian origin, or of such as, after the dissolution of their marriage with persons of foreign nationality, have contracted a marriage with Russian subjects, to acquire Russian nationality, no provisions exist in the law; in view, however, of the fact that the law, as a general rule, forbids foreign Jews to enter into Russian nationality, it must be decided that children of the marriage described above likewise do not possess the right to acquire Russian nationality."

Rostow am Don. As may be gathered from the "Pridneprowskij Kraj," the following trial took place not long ago in the court chamber of Rostow am Don