Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 4 · 22 January 1904
14printed page
scan 14 of 20

Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 4.

To master the colossal material, a Society for the Advancement of the Science of Judaism has now also been formed, which has made the treatment of the whole great field of Jewish learning its task. The term "Science of Judaism" is not of to-day, and already more than eighty years ago a few enthusiastic young men, eager for action, wished by means of a science of Judaism — even the dullest must recognise the progress of our age — to banish from the world the hatred of the Germans for the Jews. If the accession of the famous Hamburg Temple Union, one of whose committee declared that there was more Judaism in the stuffed rabbis of the zoological museums than in a living Temple preacher, was bound to discredit the endeavours of the Culture Society from the outset, then upon its sad dissolution, which soon followed, all who meant earnestly and well by their Judaism felt an abhorrence of any science of it; especially when they saw how its spokesman and agitator, the jurist Gans, had himself baptised without more ado, as soon as he saw in this step an advancement, not indeed of science, but of his civil career. So miserably ended this society, the immature product of nebulous and over-hasty storming. The only one who, at this collapse, did not, like the other co-founders, despair of the possibility of saving Judaism, was Zunz. In the pursuit of learning he found comfort and support all his life long: What alone emerges imperishable from this Mabul is the Science of Judaism. He has been proved right; since then the pursuit of it has continued without interruption.

But naturally, in the period that followed, scholarly endeavours could find no favour among conservative elements, when Geiger, a young man of twenty-five, founded a journal of Jewish theology whose whole activity culminated in utterly destroying the Judaism dependent upon Mishnah and Talmud. It contrived, with fraudulent dexterity, to re-stamp the rabbis as preachers and pastors; whether in so doing it achieved anything for the Science of Judaism is not settled, since Geiger used his science precisely for the purpose of completely dissolving Judaism, the Judaism handed down of old. He thereby at the same time created the appearance and gave rise to the prejudice that the preservation of Judaism could be carried out only in opposition to, and only at the expense of, the spirit of science. Even the eminent achievements of Zunz, who worked with German thoroughness, could not destroy this prejudice, since he aimed through them, if only in the second place, at furthering Reform. It seemed for a long time as though the pursuit of the Science of Judaism were the privilege, nay the very property, of one religious party …

And to-day, what a change! If we now survey the names, in part most illustrious, among them even some of European renown, which the Outline of the Science of Judaism enumerates, we find that the cleavage described above has vanished, that scholars of all tendencies, Conservatives and Neologues, have here come together to perform a national work of culture. How has this unanimous co-operation become possible in most recent times?

The cultivation of the Science of Judaism rests upon the insight that only through learning, that is, through bringing our teaching and our history before our eyes, can self-knowledge, a knowledge of the past, be prepared. This is the necessary precondition of self-consciousness, self-confidence and self-respect — a party fanatic might here quote § 3 of the Basle Programme — which we must acquire if we wish to win the respect of others. (In so far the Science of Judaism is also Zionist work, even in the sense of the party.) Such was the view of all the great scholars in the second half of the last century, and it must remain so in future as the only right one, without wishing thereby to deny the importance of art and poetry for the raising of self-consciousness. This had to be emphasised, although it was not learning, as those men had believed, that was able to gather the scattered members of our people under one great banner; that only the national idea could do. Yes, the same driving forces, the same impetuous urge that caused Zionism to swell into this mighty popular movement, animated these scholars too, and created for itself, as in Zionism, an organisation among them. Here also brothers who had become enemies have once more joined hands in order together to restore the honour of their mother. Long enough had strangers been left to play the lords and masters in our own house. It is positively shameful that we have looked on while Protestant scholarship has, in most recent times, dismembered the Bible, and above all the Pentateuch, like a corpse. A later generation will perhaps find it most remarkable how, proceeding from the so unsteady basis of a constructed philology, men have doubted authorships and built up new hypotheses; and it will grasp the irony that the very people who are the heralds and parrots of this newest science smile down superiorly upon the dialectical burrowings and lawyer-like pettifoggery of the Talmud. Such a thoroughly modern exposition of Isaiah is, after all, nothing but a warming-up of Schleiermacher's aims: one busies oneself with the Bible in order to belittle the people of the Bible. The merit of the Society in seeking to bring about a change in this field, and to investigate Jewish literature with a Jewish spirit and Jewish love, cannot be overestimated.

From the standpoint here emphasised — that the founding of the Society for the Science of Judaism signifies in itself a reconciliation of opposites, and in its consequences even a step towards the realisation of the Zionist programme — one can well understand, and can only find it consistent, that the "Israelit" directs its attacks against it. In an anonymous article it openly expresses its vexation that scholars, in spite of their conservative views, could take part in this national work. It simply wants no reconciliation; that is the deep gulf that separates it from Zionism. But in its opposition to the cause on principle, the Rhenish organ of the Centre overlooks above all that it is the Science of Judaism that will have to decide, as the last instance, when once the question of the necessity and the limits of a legitimate reform of the religious and ritual customs of Judaism is raised.

To be sure, the "Israelit" will fight that too, and it will be a hot struggle, which will soon break out with the mighty awakening of interest in religious questions. That this will be so is proved already by the brisk-pious-merry tone, the tone in the "Israelit."

Now the "Israelit" stands there as victor; it has conquered, it was bound to conquer, over a watery Judaism, purged of Bible, Mishnah and Shulchan Aruch, over a Judaism breaking with its historical tradition. Just so