No. 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 9.
I believe one can neither affirm nor deny the question out of hand. Jewish business morality is not a notion that applies to the whole community. That in certain districts Jews, particularly in earlier decades, played a certain part as money-lenders among the rural population is not to be disputed. Their sons are Prussian judges, irreproachable merchants of the first rank and well-known artists. I have known people who were highly unscrupulous in money matters and whom I should nevertheless not have counted among the lost, who even possessed decided benevolence and had heart. Sombart perhaps cannot comprehend that, because he lacks the acquaintance. Yet so it is. The same man who took 20% interest perhaps provided dowries for half a dozen poor girls and was a member of numerous charitable societies.
Naturally it has not escaped Sombart either that there is among us a disproportionately high percentage of disinterested idealists. But that does not fit into his system. Rhyme, or I devour you. Somehow the phenomenon must be pigeon-holed. And so: "When we find so many Jews with a directly opposite way of thinking, with an — one might almost say — over-strained altruistic disposition, a rigorous selflessness and a zealot's fervour against all that is self-seeking, we may conclude precisely from these phenomena of reaction the existence of the national character here described." Ah, no. That we may not.
With the same right one might maintain that the enthusiasts for the fleet are proof of the aversion to world-policy so often observed elsewhere, or that the days of Kishineff are a proof of the love of the Russian majority for the Jews! Surely a man of Sombart's eminence ought not to argue so.
In reality prophets are indeed a proof of the necessity of preaching repentance, but they are found none the less only among peoples of the highest moral standing. Does Sombart not consider the German Middle Ages to have stood in the utmost need of repentance?
And where then were the preachers of repentance? And against what manner of infamies did Elijah and Jeremiah preach? Against the falling away from the monotheistic idea. Good heavens, in the German Middle Ages that would not have been worth the beginning. There, from the days of the Flagellants down to the soldier-selling of Cassel, quite other themes would have been at hand! The Jews are simply not calculating machines to be furnished with the label "good" or "bad," but human beings with their contradictions. We have, as an ancient people of culture, more complicated characters among us than the Teutons, and the extremes of the nation as a whole are also more sharply marked with us — and withal the average result is truly not bad. The whole of mankind, after all, the decent antisemites included, still lives upon the moral conceptions of our Bible. And I believe that whoever knows the Jews will not despair of the present either.
What Sombart says of our abstract way of thinking and of our predilection for pure money-dealing also limps badly. That the Jews in Germany became preponderantly men of money is again conditioned above all by historical development. In America there are, in all truth, magnates enough in the field of jobbing, but few Jews among them. They sew trousers and cut shoes in the New York ghetto, and are thus pure producers, as they were before their emigration in Lodz or Berdytschew. And is peddling, too, perhaps a "money relation devoid of quality"? That surely cannot be maintained in earnest! There the personal relation to the individuality of the thing is truly strong enough. And of the countless artisans of Russia and Roumania Sombart appears never to have heard. To say nothing of the fact that we Zionists would like best to lead the whole people over to agriculture, which surely comprises the strongest relation of the person to the thing.
But the finest thing he permits himself is at the close of his discussion, with the assertion that the similarity of economic advance in Germany and the United States comes from the Jewish portion of the population of both states being about the same in percentage. He has not yet taken the trouble to ascertain even superficially what the Jews in the two countries do, else he would know that, whereas in Prussia, of 10,000 gainfully employed Jews, 2119 fall to industry and 5205 to trade, of 10,000 American Jews at least 7000 are poor industrial workers. And nevertheless these — who, moreover, have for the greater part been in the country only a few years — are supposed to exercise the same influence upon the economy of America as the Prussian Jews upon that of their homeland!
So judges of us a man of acknowledged scientific name. That is the objectivity shown towards us even where a favourable influence is vindicated to us. It is truly saddening. I have, to be sure, not a moment's doubt that many of our assimilationists are heartily glad of Sombart's discussion. He considers us, it is true, bad fellows, but useful ones nevertheless. What a gratifying feeling, after even that had for years no longer been conceded to us!
Let us hope a time will come in which we shall have the opportunity to show, by the fruits of our own administration and our own culture, what we are — at the risk that the nations may then perhaps lack "leaven."
Dr. Friedemann.
Jewish National Fund.
The Golden Book.
Ruben Wiker, Janowki, inscribes the Rishon le Zion Society . . . . . . . . . Kronen 252.— L. J. Maliewski, Gadjatsch, for the inscription of the Ohawei Zion Society . . . . . . . " 240.— Chowewei Zion of Brownsville . . . . . Pounds sterling 10.— For the inscription of Dr. M. Gaster, collection in T. Magurele . . . . . . . . Kronen 250.— For the inscription of Emil Zola . . . . . . " 257.36 For the inscription of the martyrs of Kishineff . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . " 661.55
*
Correction.
In No. 13 it should correctly read: The Poale Zion and Chowewe Zion societies in Sokolka inscribe the Intern. Committee K 240.—. The societies of the Sopotzkin Zionist district inscribe the district and its chairman, Rabbi S. J. Rabinowitz, K 409.62.
From the Movement.
Remember the Shekel!
Preliminary Notices.
Vienna. (Brigittenau Branch Society of "Zion.") Monday the 11th inst., 8 o'clock in the evening, at the Café Körner, XX., Wallensteinstrasse 2, lecture by Mr. O. Marmorek, architect. Subject: "Why are not all Jews Zionists yet?"
On the evening following the Sabbath of Shemot (9 January) the preparatory meeting of the society "Ivriyah" will take place in the Congress office. On the agenda: drafting of the statutes and election of the committee.