Letter from Herr von Plehwe to Dr. Herzl.
Minister of the Interior.
Sir!
You have expressed the wish to preserve some traces of our conversation. I gladly accede to this wish, in order to remove everything that might give rise to exaggerated hopes or disquieting doubts.
I have had occasion to acquaint you with the point of view from which the Russian Government at present regards Zionism. This point of view may indeed very easily suggest to it the necessity of exchanging its policy of toleration for measures prescribed by national self-protection. So long as Zionism consisted in the will to create an independent state in Palestine, and so long as it promised to organise the emigration of a certain number of Jewish subjects from Russia, the Russian Government could very well be favourable to it. But at the moment when this principal aim of Zionism appears to be abandoned, to be replaced by a mere propaganda for Jewish-national consolidation in Russia, it is natural that the Government can in no case tolerate this new course of Zionism. It would have no other result than to create groups of individuals who would stand entirely alien, and even hostile, to the patriotic sentiments which constitute the strength of every state.
Therefore confidence could be restored to Zionism only on condition that it return to its old programme of action. In that case it could count upon moral and material support from the day on which certain of its practical measures should serve to diminish the Jewish population in Russia.
This support might consist in the protection of the Zionist plenipotentiaries before the Ottoman Government, in the facilitating of the work of the emigration societies, and even in defraying the requirements of those societies — not, of course, from the funds of the State, but from levies raised upon the Jews.
I consider it necessary to add that the Russian Government, which is obliged to adapt its conduct in the Jewish question to the interests of the State, has nevertheless never departed from the great principles of morality and humanity. Only in the very latest period it has, indeed, extended the rights of residence within the boundaries of the districts assigned to the Jewish population, and nothing prevents the hope that the development of these measures would serve to improve the conditions of existence of the Russian Jews, especially if emigration diminishes their number.
Pray accept the assurance of my distinguished sentiments.
v. Plehvé.
30 July — 12 August 1903.