No. 2, Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 13.
(continued from page 12)
…opposition to the Action Committee. (Trietsch: Where was that?) That was at the meeting in the restaurant at the corner of the Spandauerstrasse and the Neue Friedrichstrasse (Laughter). Then there is the further fact that Herr Trietsch gradually came to enjoy the reputation of an authority on Palestine by dint of asserting it of himself. Further facts which speak in his favour have not come to my knowledge. But there are facts which speak against him, and which Professor Warburg has confirmed to me. Four years ago we, Warburg and my humble self, attempted to found a committee for the colonisation of Cyprus. Trietsch went to Cyprus at that time on the committee's behalf. He was to take charge at Trieste of those people who had previously been selected by him in Galicia, together with other gentlemen. The people were not yet in Trieste. Herr Trietsch went to Cyprus without them. The people were already disheartened by this. After two or three days they implored him to take them away out of that country again: that is the country about which Herr Trietsch writes his articles to this day. The failure did not depend upon accidental circumstances; for Herr Warburg has established that one may well found isolated villages in particular districts, but that if one sought to set on foot a mass colonisation in Herr Trietsch's sense, the people would have died of malaria by the thousand. We gave up Cyprus. When El-Arish came, we were very glad. We should have liked to see something done. But you have heard it: this country was just as incapable of colonisation by any considerable number as Cyprus. Herr Trietsch, however, had asserted with the same matter-of-factness as in the case of Cyprus that it was suited to colonisation.
Scarcely had I arrived in Palestine, at Bet Arditha, when a physician said to me: "The strangest people turn up among you." And he took a prospectus from his pocket and read it amid roars of laughter. It was the prospectus of the Oriental Colonisation Company. On page 6 he has drawn up a calculation of profitability, in which he asserted that one could live in the East on 500 marks. Against this stands the fact: the dependent peasants, who receive all manner of assistance and have pharmacy and physician free, require on average 733 francs per person. And how carefully did he draw up this calculation? He left out even the taxes, the taxes which in the East eat up one eighth of the whole income.
One thing more: had Herr Trietsch been in earnest about the movement, he would have gone to those who stood at its head and laid his plans before them. We are not here to be leaders, but to be soldiers. But what mattered to Herr Trietsch was to be no soldier, but a leader.
I must say frankly: if I have the choice of belonging to a movement in which a mistake is now and then made, with Dr. Herzl at its head, or to a movement in which people are brought to misfortune, with Herr Trietsch at its head, then I know what I want. (Stormy applause.)
Syrkin. I have taken the floor on a point of order; we have not come here to discuss at length matters which have no practical value. We are in the midst of an important discussion, and questions have been raised which undoubtedly require more serious discussion. Since we have already spent half a day for and against Trietsch, I move the closure of the debate and a passage to the further business.
Dr. Herzl. I believe it is an urgent necessity to let Trietsch have the floor. I beg you to grant it in all calm, even if you do not agree with everything. (Bravo.) Please, let him speak undisturbed!
Trietsch. Pray understand that it is a duty of honour on Dr. Herzl's part to compel the Congress to hear me. The Congress would suffer greatly if I were prevented from defending not only my personal honour, but also the honourableness of my criticism of the Action Committee. Understand me well. I have subjected the activity and policy of the A. C. to criticism. The criticism was, as I believe and as your applause has shown me, meant seriously and to the point; but the criticism was sharp, and therefore I do not wonder at the consequences, which consist in this, that I must at all costs be slaughtered. That is why Herzl had to come forward with his words, in whose correctness he believes, but which are fundamentally false. (Uproar.)
Dr. Herzl. Do you not understand that it only serves Herr Trietsch when there is disturbance; I beg you to let him speak in peace.
Trietsch. Do you not believe that, if what stands here in the protocol were true — things which happened years ago — I would hardly come to every Congress? Do you believe I would do so, if one had merely to reach into my pockets to bring forth the blackest materials against me? But the word of the leaders counts for much, and when Herzl speaks against me, I am all but crushed. Nevertheless there are friends of mine here who will bear witness that I speak the truth. The protocol speaks of Cyprus, and indeed I have had to do with Cyprus, and hope still to have to do with it. But it is not true, as the protocol says, that in a coffee-house I called upon the people to emigrate and that the mayor made up the money that was lacking. All that is untrue. After I had been in Cyprus there appeared in the "Welt" a communication from Fiume, according to which I was supposed to have done dreadful things, and Dr. Herzl wrote to me that I had no reason to complain, since serious matters had been left out. Before the last Congress I then published in the "Welt" that if anyone had anything to bring against me, let him do so, in order that I might have the opportunity of tracing the author of these rumours. No one came forward, and now, when accusations are brought against me, I hear cries of "Serves you right," and I know now that these gentlemen knew the same thing last year; the dust was allowed to settle over these matters until I became inconvenient once more, and now they are brought up again. (Uproar.)
Dr. Herzl. You see the temper of the Congress. I foresee that you will not be granted the opportunity which you desire in your own interest for the investigation of this matter, which evidently lies close to your heart, and so I will propose to you a means that is often employed. Let us elect a small committee! Before this committee you may speak your mind and hand over your material; you feel the need for these things to be cleared up, and that is worthy of the Congress. The result can then be laid before the Congress without debate. I give you the floor for 3 minutes more.
Trietsch. I asked for the floor for 3 minutes, and should like to be able to speak for 3 minutes. I regret the precious time of the Congress, but I am compelled to speak. For hours on end material