Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 24 August 1903
13printed page
scan 13 of 16

No. 1 Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 13

(continued from page 12)

…or their hearts no good testimonial. To concede the fact that the Jews are faring wretchedly ill does not, to be sure, gain very much. At most it leads to acts of charity, which in the individual case are certainly only to be praised, but which from a higher and more comprehensive point of view are to be censured, because, for all their proven inadequacy, they soothe the conscience of those who bear a common obligation. "Well, one does what one can!" is a comfortable saying. There are perhaps people who enjoy a sufficiently refined sense of self-satisfaction when, after reading of a mediaeval massacre of Jews in the morning paper, they send the newspaper a modest donation of money to be acknowledged in print. Yet even he who honestly taxes himself according to his means has not done enough with money alone. Money does not give the dead back their lives, the maimed their health, the orphans their parents. And how does one propose, with such alms, to heal the trembling of those who, though not struck in their own persons, go on living under the same conditions? They have not yet come through it.

We Zionists, in truth, employ these arguments only with inward reluctance. It goes against our feeling to exploit misfortunes politically and to draw an agitator's profit from the misery of the poorest of creatures. But it must nevertheless be said from this place with what pain and what indignation we have learned of the horrible events at Kishineff, and with what grief it fills us that Jews live under such conditions. Poor, care-laden lives have ended there under torture. We shall honour their memory and look after those they have left behind, and then we shall not lose our time in useless demonstrations, but turn our living concern to the living.

For the bloody days of the Bessarabian town must not make us forget that there is many another Kishineff, and not in Russia alone. Kishineff is wherever Jews are tormented in body or soul, wounded in their honour, injured in their property, because they are Jews. Let us save those who can still be saved.

It is high time. Whoever sees the visible signs at all must see that a positively fateful worsening of the situation has set in. We Zionists have foretold this worsening for years past — and now that it is here, we are nonetheless most painfully affected.

In the last two decades of the nineteenth century, emigration was believed in Jewish communal circles to be a universal remedy. Even if we leave everything else out of account — the misery of the wanderers, the cruelty of the new conditions into which they fell unprepared, the national loss through ever-repeated dispersions, and so forth — this could only go on so long as the countries of immigration did not resist this influx of a desperate proletariat.

This is the new epoch into which we have entered. The countries of immigration are beginning to defend themselves, although — nay, because — the distress of the Jews in the East of Europe is mounting. And yet these are countries whose high civilisation it would be simply foolish to doubt. These States believe that they must set a limit to their humanity in other respects — I do not say it ironically — and treat the Jewish question, which for them is the question of Jewish immigration, politically. Only among us Jews do many still shrink anxiously from seeing a political matter in it. This fear, however, will inspire us with more pity than anger, once we rightly understand it. It is an agoraphobia that still stems from the narrow Jews' lane.

Meanwhile things develop irresistibly. In England, the last place of refuge hitherto still quite open, a Royal Commission has been appointed to inquire into alien immigration. Of aliens, not to say of Jews The conclusions of the report, however, leave no doubt as to whose immigration the Commission had to pronounce upon. One can plainly see how free, magnanimous England struggles with herself, how hard it is for her to wring from herself a harsh measure against poor people, how she institutes a special and lengthy inquiry before she resolves upon anything definitive. For there are old principles, glorious as banners, which do not remain wholly unimpaired when England no longer grants free asylum to the innocent unfortunate. And precisely the same holds of America, which grew great because it was an asylum.

By the Governments of the countries concerned in the Jewish migration our work is better understood every day. Our solution, which seeks to help the Jewish people to a home, so entirely answers a general need that it must at last succeed. It is not, to be sure, an easy labour. There are difficulties that demand an extraordinary amount of patience and fidelity. But this in itself is a part of the education we receive along the way. There are hard days on which one sees what was won with toil melt away, and promising beginnings that then collapse upon themselves. So long as a movement is young and weak, its leaders must fear that such reverses may demoralise its adherents, and to their own disappointment and weariness is added anxiety for the continuance of the work, for the procuring of the means, for the endurance of their comrades. Yet even this is for the good. Those fall away whose loss is no loss. They depart, some with their wounded vanity, others because they did not find their account in the cause, others again because they like only to share in successes, and still others for various other reasons. But to those who remain, the cause becomes only the dearer through every sacrifice. With them one can continue on the way, and to them one can also say everything. Such was our intention when we convened this Congress, and we believed that we should have nothing else to report than the breaking-down of negotiations and the failure of long-prepared attempts. Things, however, turned out somewhat otherwise.

Since we were assembled here for the fifth time, I have twice more had the honour of being summoned to Constantinople by His Majesty the Sultan. On both occasions, however, in February as in August 1902, the negotiations remained without result. I could, of course, enter into nothing that would have been incompatible with our Basle Programme; in particular, a scattered, disconnected colonisation in various parts of the Turkish Empire could not satisfy our national needs. From all these laborious negotiations it emerged only that His Majesty the Sultan continues to preserve a friendly disposition towards the Jewish people. This is certainly gratifying and valuable, but practically it brings us no further. Since, then, the kindly disposition of the Sovereign was given, as were the undoubted advantages that the Turkish Empire would derive therefrom, the obstacle had to be sought in the attitude of the principal Powers interested in the Orient