Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 45 · 6 November 1903
9printed page
scan 9 of 20

No. 45. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.

(continued from page 8)

…"Bnei Brith," numerous Temple boards, several rabbis, many Temple officials and representatives of the most eminent Jewish institutions in Vienna. The opening address was delivered, with his accustomed mastery, by the President of the Society of the Jewish Toynbee Hall, Rector Dr. Adolf Schwarz. The address, which was heard with the closest attention and received with stormy applause, is to appear in extenso as a pamphlet, for which reason we propose to lay it before our readers only in extracts.

There is no doubt that the speaker's observations, once they are available in print, will make the most lasting impression upon wide circles. Here a serious scholar and an upright man has spoken, heedless of the approval or disapproval of his narrower colleagues in the profession and of wider circles.

Dr. David, too, the lately appointed Rabbi of the Vienna community, spoke warmly on behalf of the Jewish Toynbee Hall. The concert which followed, splendidly arranged by Mrs. Rosa Feigenbaum, was well calculated to give the guests an exalted idea of the artistic performances offered to the visitors of the Toynbee Hall.

Master Ignaz Brüll, Chief Cantor Fuchs, and the ladies Eug. Weiss, Edith and Melitta Heim met with abundant applause and, despite the lateness of the hour, were obliged again and again to yield to the demand for encores.

It was a fine and auspicious beginning for the new year of the Society.

On Sunday, the 1st of November, the lecture cycle began with a lecture by the founder of the Toynbee Hall, Prof. Dr. Leon Kellner, on S. Lublinski's book "Die Entstehung des Judentums" ("The Origin of Judaism"). The lecturer gave that concoction the dismissal it deserved.

*

From the Address of the President, Rector Dr. A. Schwarz.

… Wherein, you ask, does the essence of the Toynbee Hall consist? I should count myself happy were I in a position to give you an answer as brief as this brief question. Yet who does not know that there are things which cannot be defined, nor described, nor portrayed, for the very reason that they disclose their inner nature only to the thoughtful observer? What it is in reality, the Toynbee Hall itself could proclaim to you most eloquently. To its own regret, however, it must deny itself this so long as it lacks the room to receive a larger number of welcome guests together with its own public. It is obliged, for the present, to engage an interpreter, and as such I must from the outset forgo conveying to you in artistic form the language of immediate perception.

To describe the achievements of the Toynbee Hall exhaustively, I should have first of all to enumerate, not how much good it creates, but how much evil it prevents; how, precisely in those winter evening hours which are most perilous to the thoughtless, who know not what to do either with themselves or with their time, it becomes a staff and a support—not to say a saviour of life—to many a one who, driven to despair by the cares of want, threatens to flee from himself. Who, indeed, needs first to be told that the physician's art of forestalling every possible illness is to be valued far more highly than the art with which he knows how to dispel a disease that has already broken out? And here it must not be overlooked that moral and social diseases are the more dangerous for the very reason that, through their contagion, they more readily degenerate into epidemics. One might accordingly call the Toynbee Hall an institution of the highest importance, socially as well as culturally; but even so its essence would not be exhausted, for the reason that the fluctuating element forms an ever smaller fraction of its visitors. The Toynbee Hall has a mighty power of attraction for all who desire to cultivate and ennoble themselves, and it exercises a power of repulsion upon everyone who cannot feel at home among good people. The two to three hundred persons who gather here every evening throughout the long winter months form, as it were, one great family, whose members, after the toils and labours of the day, not only thirst for recreation but also seek and find scientific instruction and artistic edification. If one further considers that the Toynbee Hall, through the language and literature courses it has introduced, is a true continuation school for many who are eager to learn, then one must call it a place of sociability that stirs both mind and heart, but at the same time also of genuine popular education and popular ennoblement. And even with this, ladies and gentlemen, I have not named for you everything that the Toynbee Hall accomplishes and offers. For to-day I will name at least one more of its great merits: it is a Jewish institution—Jewish inasmuch as it has set itself the aim of fostering and spreading Jewish consciousness, and of awakening and heightening Jewish self-respect. That is a gain which must redound to the benefit of us all, of our entire community. For truly, in a time so profoundly sad as ours, in a time when the spectres of the Middle Ages walk abroad in terrifying fashion and the bloodiest persecutions in half-barbarous and wholly barbarous lands increase from day to day, in a time when hostile attacks from without join with desertion and apostasy within to shake the rock-wall of Judaism—in such a time the want of Jewish consciousness must be most deeply deplored and most painfully felt. (The speaker then turns to the recent massacres of Jews and to the violent attacks upon Jewish monotheism, which, it is charged against the Jews, is a borrowed possession, and then continues:)

The monotheistic idea had first to receive its embodiment, its full development, through the life of an entire people, before the promise made by God to our forefather—that he should become a blessing to the families of the earth—could be fulfilled. Monotheism had first to become a national religion before it could oppose polytheism with any prospect of success. For the course of the world's history, for the development of the human race, it is entirely immaterial in which individual the first germ of monotheistic thought can be traced; for all that matters is not with which, but in which people this seed grew up into a mighty tree. We Jews are assuredly proud of our first ancestor, but we do not for one moment conceal from ourselves that it is only as a people that we deserve, in the spiritual sense of the word, to be called the children of Abraham. What makes us Jews the chosen people is the spiritual endowment inherited from our first ancestor, which made it possible for the monotheistic idea to strike its deepest roots in us as a people and to bring its most glorious fruits to ripeness.

It is, unhappily, a widespread error that we Jews owe the idea of the one and only God to the Revelation at Sinai. The very opposite is true; it is a wholly un-Jewish, indeed a downright heathen notion, that God ever revealed Himself to one born of woman without that revelation having been preceded by the true and clear knowledge of the Supreme Being. Only after the truth had risen like a sun upon our first ancestor did he hear the voice of God; only after he von dem Da-