Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 42
(continued from page 3)
...whose number increases quite considerably every year, the opening of the railway will, finally, be greeted with especial pleasure.
Zion and East Africa.
To forestall all mistaken opinions, the Editors of "Die Welt" expressly declare that they decline responsibility for all the proposals and opinions published under the heading "Zion and East Africa". The Editors wish only to make possible the most complete discussion of this important question in every direction.
*
Two Russian Delegates on the Sixth Congress.
The Sixth Congress awakened an enormous interest in Odessa. People who until now had been indifferent, indeed even hostile, towards Zionism read the daily reports of the Congress in the daily papers with great interest. The Congress was the talk of the day among great and small, Jew and Christian. The Odessa papers carried daily telegrams, conscientious reports of the Congress from their special correspondents, leading articles on Zionism, etc., and found so ready a sale in single copies that the "Odesskija Nowosti" — to which, thanks to our friend S. Salzmann, the first place among the Russian papers is due in respect of accuracy of reporting and friendly attitude — saw itself obliged to increase its circulation considerably during and after the week of the Congress. Scarcely had the reporters learned that Sapir, Awinowitzki and other delegates had returned when the interviews already began, among which those of Mr. Treczeck in the "Od. Now." deserve the greatest recognition.
I called upon Dr. Sapir and Dr. Awinowitzki immediately after their return in order to ask their opinion. The conversations took the following course:
With Dr. Ph. Awinowitzki.
"The Sixth Congress," Dr. Awinowitzki answered in reply to my question about the results of the Congress, "is indisputably the greatest of all the Congresses hitherto. Its significance, which, as usual, is not yet clear enough to contemporaries, can be fully appreciated only by posterity, by history. The proposal of the English Government with regard to East Africa, already known to you, proves that the voice which made itself heard from the Congress tribune six years ago has been heard; that the Zionists are recognized as the representatives of the Jewish people, and that official negotiations are conducted with them. It is happening for the first time since the banishment of the Jews, and this great historical moment will remain closely bound up with the history of the Sixth Congress. Three years ago I had occasion to speak about Zionism with a highly placed personage. Among other things the following ironical remark was indelibly impressed upon my memory: 'At your Congresses you Jews merely negotiate with one another — what use is that?' I cannot recall what I answered to it, but now I should be relieved of the need to answer, because such a reproach can no longer be made against us. The same dignitary asked me: 'Why are the educated and wealthy Jews not Zionists?' I answered this delicate question with a long, far-reaching reply. To-day I should have answered briefly: 'If they are Jews, they will be Zionists.' The Sixth Congress will also bring us great benefit in another respect: it will compel the men of the pen to study the movement seriously and not to write about it at random; and if a lawyer has even just now resolved to write an article on Zionism without having the faintest notion of it, then I see in this the remnant of the childhood years of Zionism, when grown-up people permitted themselves to mock the helpless."
"Has not Palestine been pushed into the second rank by the East Africa project?"
A.: "I feel it a moral satisfaction to be able to answer you that Palestine held a place of honour at the Congress. It was resolved to begin the purchase of land in Palestine at once, and the Congress set up a permanent Palestine Exploration Commission. It meant thereby to say that no present-day programme can divert it from the goal it has set itself. The Pope will sooner cease to be a Catholic than the Zionist Congress betray Zion."
"Had Dr. Herzl the right to lay England's proposal before the Congress?"
Dr. Awinowitzki grew agitated at this question and began:
A.: "Tell me, pray — has a man who is not a physician the right to staunch a hæmorrhage from which his neighbour must perish without immediate help? Has a Spanish subject the right to pull his drowning King out of the water, although Spanish law forbids subjects on pain of death to touch the King? If you would lock up in prison the non-physician who staunched the bleeding and saved his neighbour's life, because he doctored without having the right to do so; if you may punish the Spaniard who saved his King for breaking the law — then Dr. Herzl, too, deserves punishment. Herzl knocked at the gates of Palestine. As the eagle bears its young, so would he bear the Jews on his wings to their old home; he knocked, but the lock is too fast. He would go to El-Arish, but the desert pours its sand over him; and suddenly he beholds a hand pointing to a land, and he hears a voice: 'Take, and let not thy race perish.' And Herzl is not to communicate this to the Congress, because a definite programme is laid down there? Pereat mundus, fiat justitia — let the whole Jewish people perish, but let the programme be kept? I should be dreadfully anxious for our Congress, for our standing in the world, if at the Congress it were not living Jews with Jewish hearts who had seat and vote, but dried-up mummies with a programme. Life stands above the programme. It is not the programme that makes life, but life that dictates the programme. The Zionists have always gone beyond the programme whenever their duty as Jews demanded it. Is there perhaps anything in the Basle Programme about collecting money for the Jews of Bessarabia and Roumania? But it was necessary, and the programme was enlarged. Dr. Herzl had not only the right but even the duty to negotiate with the English Government and to communicate the result to the Congress. Who can maintain that England's proposal contradicts the Basle Programme? The programme speaks of the nationalization of the Jewish elements. Did not Dr. Herzl say in a programmatic speech that we must first return to Judaism and only then to the Jewish land? We guard the beetle and do not notice the elephant walking away. We work for the Cheder and