No. 40 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11
(continued from page 10)
…found that organisation in a state which is — to other peoples — a matter of course? Zionism is certainly educative in the national sense, because it gives the persecuted and oppressed a justified pride and a shining hope; but a solution of the whole problem it can never be.
In the possibility of attaining its ideal lies the extraordinary danger of Zionism. It is of use in so far as it frankly presents the Jewish nature to Jews and Aryans; it does harm if its plan of a state miscarries. For then the disappointment would be far greater still than the hope, far more bitter the mockery and hatred of the enemies, who allow Jewry only a parasitic position because they neither comprehend nor appreciate its historic task. The bankruptcy of the Jewish State — it would mean the triumph of embittered philistinism, which is to-day the most faithful guard of the race war and wages this war with the usual weapons of all the impotent: with cursing and mistrust. From the unfitness for the state, they who are absorbed in the state without a remnant of personality remaining would infer an unfitness of the people, although the fact of an existence through thousands of years proves, as a true witness, the vitality and therewith the right to live of a people.
The probability of a collapse is not to be explained solely by the Jews' want of civic qualities. The Jew is also no coloniser — as little as the German or the Frenchman. The virtues of the British pioneers, who create homesteads out of primeval forest and prairie, are foreign to him. He does not walk behind the plough, does not till a still virgin soil, does not wrest a new culture from the earth. Swift and bold as he is in developing what is given, he is equally in need of the initiative of others. Helpless would the second-hand dealers, brandy-sellers, merchants and middlemen, the impoverished and enfeebled Jewish proletariat of Eastern Europe, stand before the mighty task. The test of Jewish colonisation has indeed already been made in Argentina; and I was able to learn on the spot how utterly it failed. So uselessly were the millions of the Baron Hirsch Foundation squandered that their interest would have sufficed to help twice as many families to an existence of independent means as there were Jews who gained a sufficient livelihood from it. In East Africa, too, the enthusiasm is lacking which for Jews attaches to the word "Jerusalem." What failed in Argentina will not succeed in Uganda.
Zionism, meritorious as an opposition, will hardly stand the test of its capacity to govern. It is very comprehensible that the surplus and discontented proletariat of the educated should long for a field of action in which to win the leading position to which its intellect seems to entitle it. But the leaders of the state lack a people fit for forming a state. Let no one believe that the adherence to national character which has hitherto hindered assimilation proves anything for Zionism. For this character is precisely hostile to the state. The Jew is — regarded as a racial type — dissolution, opposition, revolution; he is not a party of government. And only with such a one can a state live. To the negating forces of Judah the Aryan peoples oppose their affirming ones, and so check the decomposition. In a Jewish state it would set in all the more rapidly and surely, because no organism can nourish itself on negation and criticism, however witty and justified they may be.
In Basle the itinerary of Ahasuerus is being fixed. By way of Zion his road leads to Uganda. But it would be an error to suppose that his pilgrimage ends at that station. Ahasuerus must wander on, an instrument of the divine spirit, a goad in the flesh of sluggish peoples, a whip for the drowsy and the slow. Next year he will not be in
Jerusalem, and he will not remain in Uganda. He will wander, wander, wander . . .
*
In the "Jewish World" of 25th September, Mr. Samuel Daiches of Leeds, a "Nay-sayer," turns in sharp words against Zangwill and his well-known remarks on the Sixth Congress. The article runs as follows: The East Africa project is already beginning to entail serious consequences. The speech which Mr. Israel Zangwill delivered in the Great Assembly Hall on 5th September was certainly intended to defend the plan laid before the Congress by Dr. Herzl and to console its opponents. But after reading his speech I had the same feeling as I had at the Congress after the vote on East Africa. The old pain awoke, for I saw already the moral harm that East Africa has done us. From Mr. Zangwill's words there sounds (perhaps unconsciously) a contempt for the earlier Zionist activity. Does he really believe that the whole Zionist activity during the preceding seven years had no significance whatever, not even Dr. Herzl's audiences with the Sultan? I should draw from this the conclusion that purely political Zionist activity cannot count upon success. It seems evident that hitherto, as Zionists purs et simples, we were nothing but idle dreamers. Mr. Zangwill himself confirms this conclusion: he says, "We have awakened from empty dreaming." Was it all only empty dreaming? And did Mr. Zangwill himself also give himself up to this empty dreaming? I believed that Zionism had roused us from our long dream, or rather sleep. Zionism has given us back our self-respect; it has taught us to demand our human rights and to remember our historic rights; through it (Zionism) it was openly proclaimed to the world that the Jews are a people and that we live in exceedingly unworthy conditions. By means of Zionism we have demanded our ancient land, the land which gave the world its religion and its morality.
Zionism has accomplished still more. Hundreds of Jews who stood on the verge of baptism, who had altogether denied their Judaism, have declared themselves firmly and proudly as Jews and rallied round the banner of Zion. Will East Africa also make Jews into Jews? I do not believe it. And in the practical direction we founded the Colonial Bank and created the National Fund. Is all this idle dreaming? Were we therefore "men of air"? Our adversaries once said so. Must we now hear it from our fellow Zionist Zangwill?
Mr. Zangwill then speaks of the vote, and this passage pained me most of all. He described those who said "No," most of whom were from Russia, in terms which we must call unjust. We must admire not only their emotion but also their "political sechel." They oppose the East Africa plan not only from impulse of feeling but also on political Zionist grounds. Does Mr. Zangwill believe that the Nay-sayers had no inner struggle in order to remain true to their idea? He must surely also know that there were very stormy scenes in the hall of the Russian conferences. And does Mr. Zangwill think that men such as Dr. Bernstein-Kohan, Dr. Tschlenow and Engineer Temkin, who since the first Zionist Congress have been the most eminent Russian Zionists and who display a very zealous Zionist activity, understand Zionism less than he does? Is Mr. Zangwill entitled, upon such