No. 37. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
...cerned, makes it spiritually a part of the Holy Land. Dr. Herzl opened negotiations with the British Government. Both parties agreed that a Jewish expedition should be sent to investigate the possibility of settling a self-governing colony; our friend Mr. Greenberg travelled twice to Egypt to negotiate with Lord Cromer.
Unhappily the report of the expedition was hopelessly discouraging. The Sinai desert has not changed since the day when our forefathers wandered and murmured in it; indeed it has grown worse, for where near Pelusium a mouth of the Nile once wound its way through green country, there is now a desert of stone, sand and salt. But the condition of the Jewish people is more desolate still than the wilderness, and Dr. Herzl continued his negotiations, conscious that with earnest will and with labour a miracle can be wrought even though no manna falls, and that by great works of irrigation and careful organisation of the colonisation even this wilderness would blossom as the rose.
Chamberlain and Zionism.
But the difficulty of diverting the waters of the Nile for our purposes compelled the Egyptian Government to break off the negotiations. England, however, remained our friend, and Mr. Chamberlain was no less dissatisfied than we ourselves. Even amid all the cares of his South African journey Chamberlain still thought of the aspirations of Zionism, and when he passed through Egypt he put in a weighty word with Lord Cromer for the Sinai plan. When that plan then had to be abandoned, Mr. Chamberlain had a new one ready. As he travelled through the beautiful, uninhabited regions of British East Africa, a country resembling our Surrey hills, with a healthy climate, at a moderate elevation and yet so near the Equator, a land eminently suited to the white man, Mr. Chamberlain said to himself: "Here is the very land for Dr. Herzl." Indeed Mr. Chamberlain had understood that the hopes of the Zionists could not be directed to Palestine alone; for when he first made the proposal to Dr. Herzl, Dr. Herzl declared to him that his mandate did not permit him to accept any land other than Palestine or a territory neighbouring Palestine. Naturally Mr. Chamberlain could feel the importance of Palestine as Dr. Herzl did; but to him the atrocities in Kischenew, the dreadful herding of the Jews in the Russian Pale of Settlement and in the Roumanian squalor seemed worse than the setting aside of Palestine; and when he generously repeated his offer to Dr. Herzl, our leader felt that, though he had no right to accept the offer, he had still less right to decline it without laying it before the Congress. What would Zionists like Mr. Bentwich say if, which God forbid, still more terrible atrocities should occur, and if, in flight to some place of refuge, they learned that Dr. Herzl had declined this offer without saying a word to them about it? Why did Mr. Bentwich inveigh against the Fourth Congress in London, because it did nothing for the Roumanian refugees? Dr. Herzl hesitated to reject a plan of rescue for our suffering masses, not because he loves Palestine less, but because he loves his people more. For my part, I confess that I should follow the old Hebrew saying: "Leolam tikkach."
Not Palestine, but a Stage on the Road to Palestine.
Dr. Herzl was also sharply attacked by the Congress, but in what did his sin consist? In this: that, while fishing at El Arish for a piece of Palestine, he found in his net a piece of East Africa, and instead of throwing it back into the sea, brought it before the Congress and said: "My friends! It is not Palestine, and it will not become Palestine; but would it not be useful to us, while we wait, as a place of refuge for our persecuted masses, as a preliminary stage to Palestine, where we might learn to unite again, to govern ourselves, and to settle once more upon a soil?" Nor did he ask the Congress to accept or reject this unexpected accession to the forces of Zionism; he merely proposed that a commission be appointed to study the country. This simple proposal called forth passionate speeches, of which Dr. Gaster's letter to the Jewish press is a faint and belated reflection; and when, after a whole hour of voting by name, in which the "Yes" and the "No" of each delegate was like a hammer-stroke of the destiny that is forging the future of the Jewish people — when after this vote it turned out that the Noes had been beaten by 295 votes to 177, the defeated minority, for the most part Russians, left the Congress for a time, instead of accepting the decision of the majority, as is necessary in all constitutional parliaments. I could admire their emotion without admiring their political sechel (sense). Have I not said before now that the day we get Palestine will be the most terrible of days? Instead of singing songs and striking dramatic attitudes, we shall be called to action. Yet those dramatic attitudes would still have been manly compared with what followed. Imagining, strangely enough, that they had been robbed of a Palestine they had never possessed, many Russian delegates broke into hysterical tears, wrung their hands, rolled on the floor. Women fainted, men wept and lamented that it was now Tischah be Ab, and I was surrounded by a sobbing crowd begging me to come and comfort them. I very nearly wept myself, but as one weeps over the grief of children and not over that of men. And my thoughts sought comfort in the scene of the previous day, when on the great Ringplatz Zionist gymnasts, at the invitation of the Congress, proved by their muscular exercises and their agility that Jewish vitality still flows warm in the veins of our youth. The sobbing of the mourners was drowned by the tramp of the marching Zionists and the noisy applause of the enormous assembly, which greeted the physical rebirth of our race. And I said to myself that the hope of our people lies in Jewish blood and in Jewish muscles, and not in Jewish weeping and sobbing. Oh yes! It is touching, this passion for Palestine; it was moving to hear that the delegates from Kischenew rejected East Africa; but when a great country like England offers the Russian Jews a home secured by public law in her possessions, a courteous examination of this courteous offer would perhaps have been finer, if less theatrical, than this dramatic "No." And what if in the near future a swarm of Russian immigrants seeks her shores and England says no! But, moved by the suffering of several Russian delegates, I promised to come and speak at 10 o'clock at night. When I came, I found our leader occupied with the matter, and until 1 o'clock in the morning our poor, overworked leader toiled to make the simple facts clear to them. And here I will emphasise that nothing can surpass the unselfish labour of our delegates, from Herzl, Nordau or Marmorek down to the humblest adherent.
No work was too hard or too long, no rest too short. Dr. Herzl released me from my promise, and next morning the Russian delegates returned in full number to the deliberations of the Congress.