Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 17 · 24 April 1903
2printed page
scan 2 of 20

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 17.

(continued from page 1)

…ch, to produce such things — for that, surely, the members and directors of the Alliance ought to think themselves too good.

As to how matters stand, for that matter, with the school work of the Alliance, Mr. D. Haym (Caiffa) makes some apt remarks in the last number of the periodical "Palästina." We shall single out a few characteristic sentences. Mr. D. Haym writes as follows of Mikweh-Israel, the agricultural school of Jaffa, whose very name is now a positive provocation, and of the two other agricultural schools:

"In the year 1901 Mikweh-Israel had a deficit of some 130,000 Frcs., Djedeida 104,000 Frcs. If Or-Jehuda is added, the total deficit certainly amounts to 300,000 Frcs. These three agricultural schools have together about 350 pupils. Their expenditure amounts to more than half the sum required by the 109 primary schools maintained or subsidised by the Alliance, with 29,000 pupils.

Or-Jehuda is perhaps administered directly by the 'Ica.' But that changes nothing in our contention, since the 'Ica' after all covers the deficits of Mikweh-Israel and Djedeida as well, in one form or another. From this source too, without doubt, come — if not wholly, then in great part — the 287,000 Frcs. entered among the receipts of the financial report under the heading 'Subventions of the 'Ica.'

It will be granted us that these figures are no trifling ones: two million francs of outlay incurred; 500 pupils trained, or to be trained, for agriculture by Mikweh-Israel alone; for all three schools an annual budget, or rather deficit, of 300,000 Frcs."

And he sums up in another place:

"An agricultural school that turns out anything rather than farmers — petty officials, petty clerks, hawkers, etc.! How could it be otherwise? The pupils are told in every key that they are destined to sustain the stock of the colonies, that it is reckoned upon to see them raise up and revive the work called into being by the 'Ica,' and so forth. Is it wise in this way to kindle morbid ambition, to awaken pretensions which will find no satisfaction? Can one, under these circumstances, train up real farmers, who love the soil and their calling?"

What, then, is one to say to the fine phrases of the Alliance's appeal? Is the faith in its work mere self-deception? Do its directors know of all these things, and dare they nonetheless speak of their successes? Or are they themselves the deceived — they, upon whom so great a task, and one so important for our whole people, is laid?

If matters stand thus, then it is only to be regretted that Jewish benefactors have availed themselves of the Alliance's help in carrying out their plans. Then it becomes understandable, too, that the Alliance is more and more losing the universal character of which it boasts in its appeal. Then neither the President of the Anglo Jewish Association nor the President of the Israelitische Allianz of Vienna, who are especially mentioned, will be able to stay its decline.

To manage an annual income of a million and a half francs in so indescribable a fashion is simply a contempt of the entire Jewish people, if it is nothing worse.

Therefore we can only look forward with the greatest disquiet to the coming General Assembly, which will probably once again be nothing but an empty formality, trimmed with sundry compliments which the gentlemen directors fling in one another's faces.

The Alliance, this foundation of high-minded men, enthusiastic for their people and believing in its future, threatens to degenerate utterly. Only one rescue is conceivable. A return to the Jewish traditions of Crémieux and Netter! Men at its head who are willing to stand up wholly and fully for their people. The deliverance of the Jewish national idea from the fetters into which the Alliance has cast it in its schools, and above all: the speediest removal of all those who will not grasp that the Alliance has to serve Judaism, and that an open, self-confident, joyfully forward-looking and future-believing Judaism.

New Measures against the Russian Jews.

In St. Petersburg, as is known, a commission appointed by the Tsar has for a considerable time been sitting to work out measures restricting the right of the Jews to acquire immovable property in the Empire. We are in a position to give, from the minutes of the commission on the deliberations held in its sittings, the following extracts, which throw a glaring light on the situation of our fellow Jews. Prompted by the reports of the Governors of Smolensk, Pskow and Nowgorod to the Tsar, in which the Jews were blackened in unpardonable fashion, the commission appointed by the Tsar entertained the plan of depriving the Jews entirely of the right to acquire immovable property in the Empire, and of giving this prohibition retroactive force as well. The deliberations of the commission took the following course:

Finance Minister Witte said, among other things, the following: "The new bill before us for deliberation, which aims at embracing, most deeply and on every side, the whole activity of the Jews that touches upon agriculture, gives rise to doubts through its unclear drafting. The bill has drawn no exact boundary between the occupations permitted to the Jews and those forbidden them. The necessity imposed upon the Jews of carrying out the purchase and lease of immovable property outside the towns only after obtaining the permission of the administrative authority makes the exercise of civil rights dependent on the discretion of individual Governors, who will be guided in their decisions either by their personal views of the Jews or by the views of the police, which would in any case create a state of insecurity. An essential defect of the bill, however, is the fact that it makes the right to acquire immovable property, even the right already acquired to real estate, dependent upon the Jews' right of residence in the locality where the property lies; whereas this right of residence itself, under the present legislation and under the constantly shifting decisions of the Senate, holds good only for Jews who settled in the villages before 3 May 1882, or who have obtained an academic degree, or who served in the Russian army in the time of Nicholas I — that is, for persons who take little part in the commercial and industrial life of the country. The rights of residence of all the other Jews of the privileged categories and of the merchant class — those commercial and industrial persons for whom alone the bill seeks to create privileges — are, however, not clearly formulated in the law; and the Directing Senate has of late been making attempts to restrict the rights of residence even of Jewish merchants of the first guild, who already belong to the interior Governments. If, then, one wishes to subject the existing legislation on the Jews to a revision,