No. 9 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…150,000 are propination lessees, and nearly 400,000 devote themselves to trade and industry.
Judging by these figures, one would have to suppose that the Jews, in consequence of their gainful activity and the partial economic independence bound up with it, are liberal-minded elements. Unhappily the contrary is the case. The Jews, taken by and large, form a prop of the pasha-rule of the Polish szlachta and of the Galician district captains, which finds its clearest expression at the elections. The cause of this phenomenon lies in the fact that the greater part of the Jews is politically immature, and that the economic independence of the Jews is only an apparent one. The small-town Galician Jew, when he wishes to avail himself of some provision foreseen in the law, does not feel that he demands no more than is his right; rather he believes that the district captain has made him a gift of grace, for which he feels himself bound to him for ever.
This lack of understanding of his civil rights, and on the other hand the hostile, often antisemitic attitude of the authorities, especially the autonomous ones, make of the Jew, who still stands at a relatively low level of culture, a humble, will-less man. He often believes that his life depends solely on the favour of the high authorities. Such is the majority of the Jews in Galicia.
To be sure, a remarkable change has lately set in, in consequence of the penetration of the Zionist and Socialist agitations, especially in the larger towns. Naturally this process is only in the course of becoming, and there is a justified hope that conditions will in time be improved by it.
The reason why the Jews in the last decades have roused themselves to an action lies chiefly in the attitude of the Christian population towards the Jews. Although there were many among the Jews who earned certain merits for their fatherland Poland, even upon the battlefield during the Polish insurrections — for instance, Jossel Berkowicz and, in the year 1863, Dr. Bernhard Goldmann, Karlsbad, and others; although the finest types of Jewry, such as the well-known Jankel in Mickiewicz's epic "Herr Thadeusz", were glorified; although many of the Jews won themselves a considerable name in Polish literature, for example Julian Klaczko, Kraushar, etc.; although, finally, many Jews were the champions of assimilation — their position in relation to the Christian population has in essentials scarcely changed at all; they were always treated as a foreign race, as intruders.
With the assimilation of the Jews in Galicia a great swindle was in truth carried on. The height of this agitation falls in the years from 1875 to 1890. The Jews, especially the educated ones, believed at that time that if they became wholly estranged from their kinsmen they would be received with open arms by the Aryan population. During this time they even maintained an agitation paper in order to help the assimilation movement to break through the more quickly. They founded agitation societies, wrote newspaper articles, grew enthusiastic everywhere. But in vain! All the hopes which they had set upon it proved a vain delusion. Their position has changed in nothing to this day; even the most primitive, yet much longed-for wish of obtaining posts with the autonomous authorities remained unfulfilled. For example, in the whole Provincial Committee of Galicia not a single Jew is employed to this day, and the statutes of almost all municipalities (with few exceptions) contain an express provision by which it is forbidden to appoint Jews as officials. At the head of these towns stands, naturally, the capital, Lemberg! — Yes, even in private establishments, for example insurance companies such as the Cracow "Florianka", then in the Galician Savings Bank or the Galician Land Credit Institute and in many other institutions, the Jews are not employed, in spite of their assimilation.
When I once interceded for the admission of a Jewish youth to the postal service, it was declared to me quite plainly that this was impossible, for there existed a wish from Above that not more than one per cent. of Jews should be appointed out of the total number of officials.
Under such circumstances the assimilation endeavours — which, as a matter of course, had not penetrated the broader masses — had at last to be declared bankrupt. And that is quite natural. Assimilation, without a previous real and true equality of rights for the Jews, is and remains a Utopia. The Jews were asked to renounce their nationality, their religion, even their glorious traditions, and as compensation they were offered — nothing! And finally I ask: is assimilation really compatible with the spirit of progress? True progress guarantees not only to every people, to every nation, but to every individual full freedom of his development.
From this mania for assimilation, however, one lesson has remained to the Galician Jews — namely, a colossal disillusionment. The Jews have come to the conviction that, in spite of the rights contained in the Constitution, in spite of their mania for assimilation, they are always regarded socially by the Christians as men of another and lower kind; that the Christian population has almost no intercourse at all with the Jews; that in general their constitutional rights may possess perhaps a theoretical, but no practical value whatever. In spite of this theoretical equality of rights, the distinction between the Aryan citizens of higher worth and the Jewish citizens of lesser worth has remained!
When the Jews in Galicia had been cured of this fever of assimilation, there came the time of Nationalism and of Social Democracy.
The best promoter of the development of Nationalism was, first, the disillusionment that remained after the assimilation movement; then the clumsy Galician Antisemitism; and finally, in the last years, the appearance of the All-Polish idea. I shall speak only quite briefly of the last-named idea.
The All-Polish idea strives towards the goal of the restoration of the old Great Poland of the szlachta, from the Baltic to the Black Sea, and towards the denationalisation of all the other peoples dwelling in these lands, chiefly the Ruthenians and the Jews. The watchword of the representatives of this idea is: Either an All-Pole or — out! The watchword was not, indeed, openly propagated, but it is spread between the lines in the All-Polish papers. There the Ruthenians are described as enemies and the Jews as a foreign element. Of this you may convince yourselves every day if you read, for example, the "Słowo Polskie" or the "Przegląd Wszechpolski".
For Jewry in Galicia this chauvinistic All-Polish propaganda is on the one hand a great disadvantage; on the other hand it does have certain advantages. Among the Aryan population the antagonism against the Jews is, indeed, ever increasing; yet from this there follows another consequence for the Jews, namely that the feeling of belonging together begins to grow more lively among them; they draw more closely together and already today profess themselves a wholly independent nation.
In the last years Zionist societies have been founded in almost all towns and little towns, and have at once developed an intensely lively agitation. The Jewish-national pamphlets and periodicals written both at home and abroad were circulated in great numbers and also widely read. At the head of this movement stood mostly young but energetic men, such as Dr. Malz, Gerschon Zipper, Dr. Gabel, Dr. Schreiber, the brothers Stand, Dr. Bierer and many others; and the organ "Przyszłość", that is, "The Future", which they published in Lemberg, had very many readers, not only among the educated class but also among the masses of the people, and was often the object of a violent newspaper polemic. Today the Zionist party in Galicia publishes a new weekly, called "Wschód", that is, "The East", which, however — in my opinion — is written in too academic a style, whereby the effect of the paper is also somewhat weakened. Moreover, the Zionist party in Galicia lacks today capable itinerant agitators who would travel through the small towns in order to bring new forces and new material to the party. This one thing, however, I must state: that the national idea has of late penetrated more deeply into the masses.
In a certain sense as a competitor of the Zionist party, the Social Democratic party appears among us with considerable strength and also finds its adherents among the Jews in the smaller towns; and for that reason, too, there were frequent frictions and heated exchanges of opinion between the two parties, especially in earlier times.
It cannot be denied, however, that these two parties have exercised, and still exercise today, a considerable influence upon each other's adherents. Thus, for example, we formerly had many Jewish Social Democrats who were not Zionists; today, however, most Jewish Social Democrats are at the same time Zionists. The Zionists, on the other hand, have steered their political ship into more radical, often Social Democratic waters.
It sounds, indeed, very paradoxical, but the facts nevertheless speak for the correctness of my assertions.
It is characteristic, for example, that whereas only a few years ago the Jewish youth, especially in the capitals, was almost without exception of Social Democratic persuasion and in all societies cultivated intercourse with other Social Democrats, there has now, quite recently, become noticeable a movement which aims at bringing about a complete separation between the Jewish and the Aryan Social Democrats; and it was the Jewish Social Democrats who put forward the demand to form a separate, exclusively Jewish Social Democratic organisation.