No. 36. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
… The Jews see in Zionism the pleasure of being able to "pull a long nose" at the Christians. Hence they cry: "We are going away, we will stay no longer!" But the Aryans might say to this exodus: "When the gossip gets out of the cart, the cart goes the lighter!" — The "Petersburgskija Wjedomosti," too, devote an article to the Zionist Conference in Minsk, which they entitle "The Saviours of Jewry." Here, indeed, sallies against the Jews are wanting, but instead they seek to prove that the founding of a Jewish State would be a chimera. Yet they too acknowledge without reserve the powerful position of Zionism. They write, among other things: "The Zionist Conference in Minsk is a phenomenon that deserves to be discussed. The Zionist current has assumed grandiose dimensions among the Jews in Russia, so that one must reckon with Zionism. Something unusual in the history of nations is taking place before us. The Jewish masses are inspired by the idea of Zionism, are ready to sacrifice to this idea the moral and intellectual forces of the people; they dream only of the future. And this happens at the very moment when the towns and townlets of the Pale of Settlement are filled with starving Jews, when Jewish girls are perishing in houses of ill fame . ." And the paper of Prince Uchtomskij is of opinion that it would be better if the Zionist Conference in Minsk were willing to furnish the means of bringing help to the starving Jews in Russia. But therein lies precisely the error of the paper, which believes that any material means whatever could arrest the ever-spreading ruin of the Jews. The source of the specifically Jewish misfortune lies not in poverty alone, but in many other factors, which are as well known to the "Petersburgskija Wjedomosti" as to all other friends and foes of the Jews. And it is these factors that Zionism means to make disappear.
A quite different note is struck by the liberal monthly "Russkoja Bogatstwo" (Russian Wealth). Here the publicist Bikermann treats of Zionism and arrives at the conclusion that the task of Zionism, the creation of a Jewish State, is a chimera. The necessary forces that could be directed to this task are lacking; indeed, Zionism has no definite task at all; hitherto men have merely indulged in fancies on this theme. It is precisely to the illusion that underlies it that Zionism owes its relative success. Zionism and Jewish nationalism, which were called into being by the reaction, are themselves reactionary phenomena; for Zionism rests upon the notion that the enmity between non-Jews and Jews is eternal and inextinguishable. The nationalist-Zionist propaganda, which is making ever greater waves, has a thoroughly defensive tendency, and is thereby quite unavoidably led into a reactionary direction. But since precisely a progress of the Jewish people, so far as it is at all possible under present conditions, is not only important for the welfare of the Jews but also serves the preservation of the Jewish nation, the nationalist-Zionist propaganda, because it in fact works against this progress, is an anti-national phenomenon.
But what substitute could be offered the Jews for the chimera of Zionism? What ought to be done, say, in the interest of the Russian Jews? Much might be adduced: the communal constitution should be reformed, the number of schools increased, the school system in general improved, the history and the science of the Jewish people cultivated, cheap and generally accessible credit created, cheap legal aid introduced in the complicated questions of the special Jewish legislation, migration facilitated, the organization of labour assistance facilitated, the settlement of Jewish families on municipal land permitted, etc. The Jews themselves must go hand in hand in their work with the leading elements of the people among whom they live. Whatever the Antisemites and Zionists may say, the Jews are no torn-off shreds, no enclaves in a foreign land, but a living part of a living whole. If the whole body wastes away, the single part cannot thrive, and conversely. Therefore it is also the task of the Jews to labour for the welfare of the whole. That is their duty as Russian citizens, but also as Jews who have to work for the welfare of their kinsmen.
But what is to be done for the Jewish nation, if the ideas of the Nationalists and Zionists are impracticable? Here the task is — the preservation and development of Jewish national character, the preservation and elaboration of their culture, the preservation and cultivation of all that is good in this culture of theirs. Let the material and intellectual level of the five million Russian Jews be raised, let the swiftest and easiest possible transition from a mediaeval to a modern view of the world be promoted, let the Jewish people be given the opportunity to take part as a more active factor in the history of the fatherland, and one may be convinced that it will enter the arena as the Jewish people. A culture of 4000 years cannot be so lightly cast off. Once the Jewish nation takes an active part in the life of the people in whose midst it lives, it will give expression to its historico-cultural type, and that not as something stationary, but as one of the elements out of which its future historico-cultural type will be formed. The greater the number of Jews who are won for the modern view of the world and are able to intervene actively in history, the less the Jewish intelligentsia runs the danger of letting itself be absorbed by other peoples. The nationalist propaganda, which subordinates the demands of life to nationalist sentiments about the preservation of the "Jewish nation" as an end in itself, strives at bottom, despite all its fine-sounding phrases, only to arrest natural progress; it hinders the development of the Jewish people, so far as this is at all possible under present real conditions, and thereby works precisely against the preservation of the Jewish nation.
To polemicize against Herr Bikermann would be to make one stone-blind see. The "Nowoje Wremja" is, after all, far more sincere, saying bluntly: "When the gossip gets down from the cart, the cart goes the lighter." Count Ignatiew expressed this in the year 1883 in the words: "The frontier stands open to the Russian Jews ...." And what, in the opinion of the publicist of the "Russkoje Bogatstwo," the Jews lack, is precisely what Zionism means to give them — but under such circumstances that it can no longer be taken away from them. But let us be permitted one question: Is not Herr Bikermann a Jew? Only an assimilationist Jew can write thus!
But however our enemies and our professed friends may judge of Zionism, one thing even they have attested: Zionism has become a factor of power with which, nolens volens, one must reckon.
Gt.
Family Unions and Family Foundations.
The fable of the capital power of the Jews, and of the position of power founded thereon, finds believers today in serious circles neither among Jews nor among Christians. The Jews in the East are almost without exception proletarians; the West European Jews, taken as a whole, lose more capital daily through the passing over of their moneyed aristocracy to Christianity. However slight the degree in which this moneyed aristocracy may have employed the power of its capital in a Jewish sense, it cannot be denied that the total loss of that capital represents at the same time a loss of power for Jewry as a whole — unless one would deny the position of capital as a factor of power altogether. For through the passing of the capital into non-Jewish circles, the possibility of ever throwing it into the scale for purposes of all Jewry is entirely excluded. A replacement of Jewish capital is not to be thought of, because, as the last decades teach, only capital itself attracts capital. A working-up of middling Jewish capitalists to the wealth of the moneyed aristocracy is, however, impossible under the social and political conditions, now especially unfavourable to the Jews. Rather is a decline of capital power to be feared in these circles too, and has perhaps already set in in many places. With this, however, the danger of proletarianization appears to have come nearer to the West European Jews as well, and their gradual sinking to the economic level of their Eastern brethren inevitable.
Were our Jewish moneyed aristocracy also possessed of an aristocratic sense of duty, prompting it to help the hard-pressed community to the best of its powers, this development could be successfully counteracted from those circles. For that, however, the spirit of desertion prevailing there, assimilationism, would first have to be rooted out — a goal to which the way is still long and thorny enough, but which must be kept in view. Meanwhile, however, in my opinion, something must also be done in those strata of Jewry directly threatened by proletarianization, in order that the danger may be con-